How to Make Characters Resonate

by

Characters are the beating heart of any story. They are the conduits through which themes are explored, plots unfold, and emotions are evoked. Yet, countless narratives feature characters who feel flat, forgettable, or simply fail to connect with their audience. True resonance isn’t just about likeability; it’s about creating an indelible impression, a sense of shared humanity, and a connection that lingers long after the final page or credit. This guide delves into the intricate craft of forging characters that resonate deeply, not through superficial tricks, but through profound understanding and deliberate execution. We will unpack actionable strategies, providing concrete examples that elevate your character work from functional to unforgettable.

The Foundation: Beyond Archetypes and Tropes

Before we paint the nuanced layers, we must establish a robust foundation. Many creators fall into the trap of building characters on archetypes or tropes alone. While these can serve as useful starting points, they are not destinations. A character based solely on being “the reluctant hero” or “the quirky sidekick” will feel generic. Resonance demands individuality.

Deconstructing the Core: Needs, Wants, and Flaws

Every resonant character is propelled by internal forces. Understanding these is paramount.

  • Core Need (The “Why”): This is often subconscious, primal, and universal. It addresses a fundamental human desire: security, love, acceptance, belonging, control, meaning. It drives the character’s deepest motivations and fears. Example: Walter White’s core need evolves from security for his family to a need for recognition and control, a subconscious desire to reclaim agency in a life that felt passively lived. This underlying need explains his escalating actions far more profoundly than simply wanting money.

  • Expressed Want (The “What”): This is the character’s conscious goal, what they actively pursue in the plot. It might directly align with their need, or it might be a misguided attempt to fulfill it. The tension between need and want often fuels internal conflict. Example: Sarah Connor’s want in ‘Terminator 2’ is to protect John. Her deeper need, however, is to overcome the fear and trauma of her past and become a capable, self-reliant protector, not just a victim. The journey of the story tests the connection between her want and her need.

  • Defining Flaw (The “How It Goes Wrong”): A flaw is not a weakness to be eliminated, but an inherent, often paradoxical, aspect of the character that creates internal and external conflict. It’s the Achilles’ heel that makes them human, relatable, and prone to error. Crucially, the flaw should intersect with their need and want. Example: Tony Stark’s defining flaw is his arrogance and desire for control, stemming from a need for validation. While it fuels his genius, it also leads to isolation, impulsive decisions, and repeatedly puts him and others in peril, forcing him to confront the limits of his own perceived infallibility. This intertwining makes his flaw an integral part of his identity and journey.

Crafting a Compelling Backstory (and Not Overusing It)

A character’s past shapes their present. A well-conceived backstory provides psychological depth, explaining their beliefs, fears, skills, and even their mannerisms. However, a backstory is for you, the creator, more than it is for the audience to consume in exposition dumps.

  • The “Iceberg” Principle: Only 10% of the backstory should be visible on the surface. The remaining 90% informs your character’s reactions, decisions, and personality, without needing explicit explanation. Example: We don’t need a detailed monologue about Han Solo’s youth smuggling to understand his cynicism, self-preservation instincts, and underlying loyalty. His actions and dialogue subtly reveal a past of hard knocks and self-reliance. The audience infers, which is more engaging than being told.

  • Backstory as a Catalyst, Not a Crutch: The past should inform the character’s current motivations and struggles, not entirely excuse or dictate them. It’s a wound or a blessing that shapes their journey, not a static explanation for their entire being. Example: Batman’s parents’ death is critical. It’s the catalyst for his vigilante life, but his continued struggle isn’t just about avenging them, it’s about protecting Gotham, stemming from a deeper need for order and preventing others from experiencing his trauma. His past constantly influences his choices, but doesn’t define the entirety of his complex moral compass.

The Art of Showing, Not Telling: Manifesting Character

Resonance isn’t built on declarative statements (“He was brave”). It’s built on observable actions, revealing dialogue, and internal thought.

Action and Reaction: The Definitive Reveals

A character’s choices under pressure, their immediate responses, and their long-term habits speak volumes.

  • Revealing Choices: What does a character do when faced with a moral dilemma? When safety is on one path and principle on another? Example: Instead of stating a character is selfish, show them taking the last piece of food, even when others are clearly hungrier. Or, show them prioritizing their own comfort over helping someone in distress. These small, seemingly insignificant choices accumulate to paint a vivid portrait.

  • Contradictory Actions (The Human Element): People are not always consistent. A character who attempts selfless acts but occasionally succumbs to their flaw (e.g., the noble knight who secretly struggles with envy) feels more real. This inconsistency adds texture and depth. Example: A politician who champions environmental causes but then takes private jets for short trips. This hypocrisy, if subtly presented, makes them feel more multidimensional and less like an ideal.

  • Physicality and Habit: How they walk, hold themselves, their nervous tics. These details provide immediate, non-verbal insight. Example: A character who constantly checks their watch and avoids eye contact might be anxious or deceitful. A character who always has a book in hand and speaks in a measured tone suggests thoughtfulness and introversion.

Dialogue: Beyond Information Exchange

Dialogue is a powerful tool for characterization, but it’s often misused to simply advance the plot or provide exposition. Resonant dialogue reveals personality, relationships, and internal states.

  • Voice and Idiosyncrasies: Every character should have a distinct voice. This includes word choice, sentence structure, rhythm, and unique phrases. Do they use slang? Formal language? Are they verbose or succinct? Example: Yoda’s inverted sentence structure ( “Powerful you have become, the dark side I sense in you.”) is iconic and immediately recognizable, reflecting his ancient wisdom and unique perspective.

  • Subtext and Unsaid Things: The most powerful dialogue often lies in what isn’t said, or what is implied beneath the surface. What are they really trying to communicate? What emotions are they hiding? Example: A tense conversation between estranged siblings might involve seemingly polite pleasantries, but the sharp edges, the pauses, the avoidance of certain topics, reveal deep-seated resentment or unresolved issues.

  • Dialogue Driven by Need/Want/Flaw: Every line a character speaks should, in some way, serve their underlying motivations or expose their vulnerabilities. Example: A character driven by a need for control might constantly interrupt others, ask leading questions, or try to manage situations through their speech.

Internality: The Unseen Depths

While external actions are crucial, a character’s internal landscape—their thoughts, fears, hopes, and memories—provides unparalleled depth.

  • Inner Monologue (Judiciously Used): When appropriate, a glimpse into a character’s direct thoughts can forge a powerful connection. This is particularly effective in first-person narratives or where an omniscient narrator can delve into minds. Example: In literary fiction, extended internal monologues often reveal a character’s anxieties, self-doubt, or philosophical musings, allowing the reader to experience their psychological journey directly.

  • Emotional Arc: Resonance means experiencing a rollercoaster of emotions with the character. This requires showing their emotional responses, not just stating them. Fear manifests as trembling hands, a racing heart, or paralysis. Joy as a broad smile, tears, or a spring in their step. Example: Rather than “She felt sad,” show the character gazing out a window, a single tear tracing a path down her cheek, or finding herself unable to focus on daily tasks.

  • Perspective and Worldview: How does the character interpret events? Their unique lens on the world filters everything. Example: Two characters witnessing the same accident might have vastly different reactions: one sees a tragic inevitability, the other, an opportunity for heroic intervention. Their perspectives reveal their inherent optimism, cynicism, or sense of duty.

The Journey: Evolution and Relatability

Static characters are forgettable. Resonant characters evolve, change, and grow (or sometimes, tragically, decline). Their journey is what makes them compelling.

The Arc of Change: Transformation and stasis

A character arc isn’t always about becoming “better.” It’s about fundamental change, for good or ill, or the profound choice not to change despite immense pressure.

  • Positive Arc: The character overcomes their flaw, fulfills their true need, and achieves a greater understanding of themselves and the world. Example: Scrooge McDuck’s arc in ‘A Christmas Carol’ from a miserly, isolated figure to a generous, caring individual who embraces his community. His need for security gives way to a need for connection.

  • Negative Arc: The character succumbs to their flaw, makes destructive choices, and descends further into despair or villainy. Example: Anakin Skywalker’s tragic transformation into Darth Vader. His need for control and fear of loss, coupled with his impatience and anger, consume him, ultimately leading to destruction.

  • Flat Arc: The character resists significant internal change but deeply impacts others or their environment. Their unwavering nature is the strength the story explores. Example: Gandalf in ‘Lord of the Rings.’ He is wise and powerful initially, and while he faces challenges, his core values remain steadfast. His presence is a catalyst for the arcs of others.

Relatability vs. Likability: The Nuance of Connection

Many mistake likability for relatability. A resonant character isn’t necessarily a “good” person, but they must possess qualities or experiences that allow the audience to connect, empathize, or understand.

  • Shared Human Experience: Everyone knows fear, love, loss, ambition, self-doubt, or the sting of betrayal. Tapping into these universal human emotions and experiences allows for immediate connection, regardless of a character’s fantastical circumstances. Example: Despite being a wizard in a magical world, Harry Potter’s feelings of loneliness, his struggle with grief, and his desire for belonging are profoundly relatable.

  • Flaws as Connectors: It’s often a character’s imperfections, not their perfections, that make them relatable. We see ourselves in their struggles, their mistakes, and their efforts to overcome them. Example: Jesse Pinkman’s moral struggles, his moments of weakness, and his desire for acceptance in ‘Breaking Bad’ often make him more relatable to the audience than the increasingly manipulative and sociopathic Walter White.

  • Moral Ambiguity: Characters who operate in shades of grey often feel more real and therefore more resonant than purely good or evil figures. Their internal conflicts and difficult choices invite contemplation and empathy. Example: Jaime Lannister’s arc in ‘Game of Thrones’ beautifully illustrates moral ambiguity. He starts as a villain and slowly unveils layers of honor and complexity, forcing the audience to re-evaluate their perception of him.

Stakes: Why Does the Audience Care?

Characters resonate when the audience is invested in their journey. This requires clear, meaningful stakes.

  • Internal Stakes: What does the character stand to lose or gain on a personal, psychological level? Their sense of self? Their moral compass? Their identity? Example: If a character is trying to forgive someone, the internal stake is their peace of mind, their ability to move forward, or the very nature of their relationships.

  • External Stakes: What are the tangible consequences in the plot? Life, death, freedom, success, failure? Example: If a character is trying to stop a bomb, the external stake is the lives of thousands and the destruction of a city.

  • Combined Stakes: The most resonant stories intertwine internal and external stakes. The character’s external journey forces them to confront internal demons or make profound personal changes. Example: In ‘Star Wars: A New Hope,’ Luke’s external quest to destroy the Death Star is intertwined with his internal quest to find his place in the galaxy, embrace his destiny, and overcome his provincial past.

The Polish: Refining and Deepening Resonance

Even with a strong foundation and compelling journey, subtle refinements can elevate a character to iconic status.

Unique Mannerisms and Habits

Small details make characters distinct and memorable. These aren’t just quirks; they should organically stem from the character’s personality, backstory, or current struggles.

  • Verbal Tics: A particular phrase they always use, a stutter when nervous, a tendency to repeat words. Example: Captain Jack Sparrow’s flamboyant speech patterns and peculiar turns of phrase are integral to his character.

  • Physical Habits: How they fidget, their posture, a signature gesture. Example: Sherlock Holmes’s meticulous attention to detail, observed in his precise movements and analytical gaze, reinforces his intellectual prowess.

  • Signature Props: An item intricately linked to them. Example: Indiana Jones’s fedora and whip are extensions of his adventurous, resourceful persona. These are not just accessories; they are symbols that tie back to their identity or role.

Relationships: The Mirrors of Identity

Characters are defined not only by who they are individually, but by how they interact with others. Relationships serve as crucial mirrors, reflecting different facets of a character’s personality.

  • Contrasting Relationships: How does a character act with a loved one versus an enemy? With a superior versus a subordinate? This reveals their malleability, their power dynamics, and their true nature. Example: The stark contrast between how Severus Snape treats Harry Potter (with disdain and hostility) versus how he secretly cherishes Lily Potter’s memory (with profound, selfless love) reveals his complex inner turmoil and true loyalty.

  • Foil Characters: Characters designed to highlight or contrast the qualities of another. They bring out aspects of the primary character that might otherwise remain hidden. Example: Dr. Watson is the perfect foil for Sherlock Holmes, grounding his eccentric brilliance and providing a window into his humanity (or lack thereof).

  • Evolving Relationships: Relationships are dynamic. They should twist, turn, break, and mend, reflecting the characters’ own growth or decline. This shows real emotional depth and consequence.

Thematic Connection: Character as Embodiment

Resonant characters are often embodiments of the story’s core themes. They don’t just exist within the narrative; they explore its central ideas.

  • Symbolic Representation: Does the character represent hope, despair, justice, corruption, or redemption? Their journey then becomes a powerful exploration of that theme. Example: Katniss Everdeen in ‘The Hunger Games’ becomes a symbol of rebellion and hope against oppression, her personal struggle directly reflecting the broader societal themes of the series.

  • Challenging the Theme: Sometimes, a character subverts or challenges the prevailing theme, adding complexity. A character who claims to fight for justice but relies on injustice, for instance.

  • Driving the Theme: The character’s choices and actions should directly influence the thematic exploration, not just react to it. They are active participants in shaping the narrative’s message.

The Pitfalls to Avoid: Draining Resonance

Even with the best intentions, certain practices can actively diminish character resonance.

Over-Exposition and Info-Dumping

Drowning the audience in backstory, psychological profiles, or detailed explanations of a character’s traits will make them disengage. Let the audience discover the character through their actions and subtle cues. Trust them to connect the dots.

Perfect Protagonists and Pure Villains

Characters without flaws are unrelatable; villains without motivations are uninteresting. Avoid saccharine heroes or moustache-twirling antagonists. The real world is rarely black and white, and neither should your characters be.

Inconsistent Characterization

Once you’ve established a character, maintain consistency in their core traits and motivations, even if they evolve. Sudden, unearned shifts in personality or abilities will break the audience’s immersion and trust. If a character changes, show the compelling reasons and the internal struggle behind it.

Lack of Agency

Characters who are merely passive recipients of plot points, always reacting and never initiating, rarely resonate. Give your characters desires, goals, and the courage (or foolishness) to act on them. They must drive the story, not merely be dragged along by it.

Redundancy

Avoid creating characters with overlapping functions or identical personalities. Each character should serve a unique purpose and bring a distinct perspective to the narrative. If you can remove a character without the story unraveling, they probably aren’t essential and are diluting the impact of others.

The Enduring Power of Resonance

Creating characters that resonate is an ongoing journey of empathy, observation, and meticulous craftsmanship. It demands that you delve into the fundamental workings of the human psyche, understanding motivations beyond the superficial, and expressing them through nuanced actions and profound internal lives. When you succeed, you don’t just tell a story; you create an experience. You gift your audience not merely a plot, but a mirror, a window, and a memory. The characters you forge will live beyond the confines of your narrative, becoming touchstones, companions, and silent reflections of the universal human spirit. They will whisper their truths in the quiet moments, remind us of our own struggles and triumphs, and leave an indelible mark on our hearts and minds. That is the true power, and lasting legacy, of resonance.