How to Plot Your Novel’s Conflict

by

How to Plot Your Novel’s Conflict

The heart of every compelling story beats with conflict. It’s the engine that drives your plot, reveals character, and keeps readers turning pages late into the night. Without well-crafted conflict, your narrative flatlines, your characters remain stagnant, and your reader’s interest wanes. This isn’t just about explosions and fistfights; it’s about the deep-seated clashes – internal and external – that force your characters to change, to grow, and to earn their ultimate victory or face their devastating defeat.

Forget the simplistic idea that conflict is merely an obstacle. It’s a precise instrument, a carefully tuned mechanism that orchestrates your entire narrative. This comprehensive guide will dissect the art and science of plotting novel conflict, providing you with actionable strategies and concrete examples to elevate your storytelling from concept to captivating reality.

Understanding the Anatomy of Conflict: More Than Just a Problem

Before we dive into the ‘how,’ let’s clarify the ‘what.’ Conflict isn’t just a problem your character faces; it’s the struggle against an opposing force that creates tension and demands a resolution. It’s the friction that sparks the narrative flame.

Every robust conflict possesses several key components:

  • The Protagonist’s Goal: What does your main character desperately want? This isn’t a fleeting desire; it’s the core aspiration that drives their journey. It must be clear, tangible (even if metaphorical), and have high stakes attached.
    • Example: In a mystery novel, the detective’s goal is to identify and apprehend the killer before they strike again.
  • The Antagonistic Force: What or who stands in the way of your protagonist achieving their goal? This isn’t always a villain with a black hat. It can be nature, society, an internal struggle, or even the protagonist’s own flaws.
    • Example: The antagonistic force against the detective could be a cunning, elusive killer, a corrupt police department, or the detective’s crippling self-doubt.
  • The Stakes: What will your protagonist lose if they fail to achieve their goal? The stakes must be significant and personal, making the reader deeply invested in the outcome.
    • Example: For the detective, the stakes might be the lives of future victims, their career, their reputation, or even their own life.
  • The Tension: The emotional and psychological pressure buildup created by the clash between the goal and the antagonistic force. Tension is what keeps readers engaged and guessing.
    • Example: The ticking clock of another potential murder, the psychological games played by the killer, or the detective’s internal struggle with their past failures all create tension.
  • The Resolution (or Lack Thereof): How does the conflict conclude? Does the protagonist succeed, fail, or achieve a bittersweet outcome? The resolution should feel earned and impactful.
    • Example: The detective might solve the case, but at a great personal cost, or fail the case but learn a vital lesson about themselves.

The Two Pillars: Internal vs. External Conflict

Novel conflict isn’t monolithic. It primarily manifests in two crucial forms, often intertwined:

External Conflict: The World Against the Character

This is the most overt form of conflict, involving the protagonist battling forces outside themselves. These are the struggles that drive the visible plot.

  • Character vs. Character: The most common form, where two or more characters’ differing goals, values, or desires clash. This isn’t limited to hero vs. villain; it can be rivalries, misunderstandings, or ideological differences.
    • Example: A brutal queen oppressing her subjects versus a rebellion leader. Two siblings vying for their parents’ inheritance. A protagonist trying to convince a friend to abandon a destructive path.
  • Character vs. Nature: The protagonist battles the raw, untamed forces of the natural world – storms, wild animals, disease, desolate landscapes. This highlights human vulnerability and resilience.
    • Example: A sailor battling a hurricane at sea. A hiker lost in a blizzard. Survivors of a pandemic trying to find a safe haven.
  • Character vs. Society: The protagonist clashes with the rules, norms, laws, or dominant ideology of a social group, institution, or entire civilization. This often explores themes of justice, rebellion, and individuality.
    • Example: A dissident fighting against a dystopian government. An individual challenging deeply ingrained prejudices in their community. A lawyer fighting a corrupt legal system.
  • Character vs. Technology/The Supernatural: The protagonist faces advanced technology gone awry, artificial intelligence, or supernatural entities like ghosts, demons, or magic.
    • Example: A scientist battling a rogue AI that has enslaved humanity. A priest confronting a demonic possession. Survivors navigating a world overrun by zombies.

Internal Conflict: The Battle Within

Equally, if not more, important, internal conflict is the struggle within the character’s own mind, heart, and soul. It often stems from their vulnerabilities, fears, beliefs, and past experiences. Internal conflict makes characters relatable and complex, and it drives character arc.

  • Choice/Dilemma: The character faces a morally challenging or deeply personal decision with significant consequences, where no easy answer exists.
    • Example: A soldier must choose between following orders that will harm innocent civilians or disobeying, risking court-martial. A character torn between pursuing their dreams and fulfilling family obligations.
  • Self-Doubt/Fear: The character struggles with insecurity, a fear of failure, or a past trauma that hinders their progress. This often manifests as imposter syndrome, crippling anxiety, or a belief they are unworthy.
    • Example: A brilliant scientist who doubts their own abilities and is afraid to present their groundbreaking research. A character tormented by a past mistake, preventing them from forgiving themselves.
  • Conflicting Beliefs/Values: The character holds two or more contradictory beliefs or values that cause internal turmoil.
    • Example: A highly religious character who witnesses profound injustice and questions their faith. A character who believes in absolute personal freedom but also feels a strong pull towards communal responsibility.
  • Personality Flaws/Vices: The character’s own negative traits – arrogance, greed, envy, anger, addiction – hinder their progress or cause harm to themselves or others. Overcoming these flaws is often the core of their arc.
    • Example: An arrogant protagonist who refuses to ask for help, leading to repeated failures. A character battling an addiction that jeopardizes their most important relationships.

The Synergistic Relationship: External and internal conflict are rarely isolated. A truly powerful narrative weaves them together. External pressures often exacerbate internal struggles, and internal growth (or regression) directly impacts a character’s ability to navigate external challenges.

  • Example: A detective battling a cunning killer (external conflict) also struggles with a crippling fear of failure due to a past case (internal conflict). The external pressure of the ticking clock amplifies their internal demons, forcing them to confront them. When they overcome that fear internally, they gain the clarity and conviction needed to apprehend the killer externally.

The Conflict Arc: Building Momentum and Escalation

Conflict isn’t a static element; it evolves and intensifies throughout your novel. Thinking of conflict as an ‘arc’ ensures dynamic pacing and escalating stakes.

The Inciting Incident: Sparking the Fire

This is the event that shatters the protagonist’s ordinary world and thrusts them into the central conflict. It must be significant enough to disrupt their status quo and force them into action.

  • Concrete Example: For the detective, the discovery of a mutilated body with a chilling signature. For a fantasy hero, the discovery of a dark prophecy or the invasion of their peaceful village.

Rising Action (Escalation): Turning Up the Heat

This is the bulk of your novel, where the conflict steadily builds. Each scene, each setback, each new piece of information should raise the stakes and intensify the pressure on your protagonist.

  • Increasing Stakes: What was originally at risk should grow. If it was just their reputation, now their life, or the lives of loved ones, are on the line.
  • New Obstacles & Complications: The path to the goal is never straight. Introduce new challenges, twists, and betrayals. The antagonist should prove to be more formidable than initially thought.
    • Concrete Example (Detective): The first victim is found. Then, a second victim with a similar signature, but this time a personal connection to the detective emerges. The police chief pulls them off the case. They uncover evidence that implicates someone close to them. They receive a chilling message directly from the killer.
  • Sacrifice and Loss: To underscore the difficulty of the journey, your protagonist should suffer losses – not just physical, but emotional, relational, or even moral. These sacrifices underscore the cost of their pursuit.
  • Character Transformation (Internal Conflict Manifesting): As external pressures mount, the protagonist is forced to confront and evolve their internal conflicts. Old habits fail, old beliefs are challenged, and they must adapt.

The Midpoint: A New Perspective or Heightened Stakes

Often, around the middle of the novel, a significant event occurs that fundamentally shifts the protagonist’s understanding of the conflict or dramatically increases the stakes. This isn’t the climax, but a pivotal moment that redirects the narrative energy.

  • Concrete Example (Detective): The detective realizes the killer isn’t just targeting random people, but executing a complex, personalized vendetta that directly involves the detective’s past. The game just became far more personal and dangerous.

The Climax: The Ultimate Showdown

This is the peak of the conflict, the moment the protagonist directly confronts the main antagonistic force. All the accumulated tension, all the internal and external struggles, converge here. This battle isn’t necessarily physical; it can be a moral confrontation, a passionate debate, or a desperate act of self-sacrifice.

  • No Easy Wins: The protagonist should be at their most vulnerable, facing seemingly insurmountable odds. Their victory, if it comes, must be hard-won and earned.
  • Resolution of Main Conflict: The primary goal established at the beginning is either achieved or definitively lost.
  • Display of Character Transformation: The protagonist should demonstrate the growth they’ve undergone throughout the story, using their newfound strengths or understanding to face the ultimate challenge.
    • Concrete Example (Detective): The detective tracks the killer to their lair, a place resonant with the detective’s own past trauma. They engage in a tense psychological and physical battle, where the detective’s previously crippling self-doubt is overcome, allowing them to outwit and apprehend the killer, but not without revealing a dark truth about their shared histories.

Falling Action & Resolution: The Aftermath

The immediate aftermath of the climax, where loose ends are tied up, and the consequences of the climax unfold. This resolves the immediate emotional tension. The ultimate resolution shows the lasting impact of the conflict on the protagonist and their world. This isn’t just “happily ever after” – it’s “how has this person and their world changed because of what they went through?”

  • Concrete Example (Detective): The killer is incarcerated. The detective deals with the media frenzy and the personal fallout. They find a measure of peace, having confronted their past, but carry indelible scars, perhaps choosing a new path in life less burdened by their previous demons.

Strategizing Conflict: Plotting with Focus

Now that we understand the components and arc of conflict, let’s look at actionable strategies for plotting it effectively.

1. Define Your Protagonist’s Deepest Desire and Core Flaw

Your story’s conflict must be rooted in your protagonist. What do they truly want, beyond surface-level desires? And what is their biggest internal obstacle preventing them from getting it? This “want vs. need” dynamic is crucial.

  • Actionable Step: Create a character profile.
    • Goal (External Want): What tangible thing do they pursue?
    • Need (Internal Want/Flaw to Overcome): What emotional or psychological truth must they learn? What character flaw must they conquer?
    • Why they Want it: What past experiences or core values drive this desire?
    • Why they Can’t (Yet): What internal flaw or external obstacle is currently preventing them?
  • Example:
    • Protagonist: Evelyn, a renowned but cynical investigative journalist.
    • Goal: Expose the corruption of a powerful mayoral candidate.
    • Need: To trust others again after being betrayed by a source early in her career, which makes her isolate herself and refuse to work with anyone.
    • Why she Wants it: Believes in truth and justice, but also seeks professional validation.
    • Why she Can’t (Yet): Her cynicism and distrust push away potential allies and make her overly cautious, slowing her investigation.

2. Craft a Formidable and Personal Antagonistic Force

The antagonist isn’t just evil; they are an opposing force with their own goals, motivations, and often, their own internal conflicts. Make them a worthy adversary, deeply connected to your protagonist’s goals and fears.

  • Actionable Step: Develop an antagonist profile mirroring your protagonist’s.
    • Antagonist’s Goal: What do they want, and why?
    • Antagonist’s Motivation: What drives their actions? Is it power, survival, a twisted sense of justice, or fear?
    • Antagonist’s Relation to Protagonist: How do their goals directly clash? How can they exploit the protagonist’s flaws?
    • Antagonist’s Strengths: What makes them powerful or difficult to defeat?
    • Antagonist’s Flaws/Vulnerabilities: Where can they be exploited? Even villains have weaknesses.
  • Example (Building on Evelyn):
    • Antagonist: Mayor Thomson, a charismatic and seemingly benevolent public figure.
    • Antagonist’s Goal: Secure his re-election and consolidate his power, continuing his corrupt schemes.
    • Antagonist’s Motivation: A deep-seated belief that the ends justify the means. He sees himself as a strong leader who must make tough, even immoral, decisions for the greater good (his version of it).
    • Antagonist’s Relation to Protagonist: Thomson knows Evelyn’s reputation for distrust and actively uses it against her, planting false leads and discrediting her by highlighting her isolation and history of being burned. He represents the system that broke Evelyn’s trust in the first place.
    • Antagonist’s Strengths: Public relations mastery, deep pockets, network of loyal (or intimidated) allies, apparent moral high ground.
    • Antagonist’s Flaws: Arrogance, underestimation of his opponents, a ruthless streak that can be exposed.

3. Brainstorm Core Conflicts for Each Act/Major Plot Point

Don’t just think “conflict.” Think about what specific conflicts will arise at different stages of your story. This helps with pacing and escalation.

  • Actionable Step: For your Inciting Incident, Three Act structure (or whatever structure you use), and major turning points, identify the primary external and internal conflicts.
    • Beginning: What sets the conflict in motion? What internal struggle is immediately apparent?
    • Middle: How do the external pressures increase? What new moral dilemmas or personal fears arise?
    • End: What is the final, ultimate external confrontation? How is the internal struggle resolved or transformed?
  • Example (Evelyn):
    • Beginning:
      • External: Evelyn receives an anonymous tip about Thomson’s corruption, but the source is unreliable.
      • Internal: Her immediate reaction is skepticism and a refusal to trust the source, almost prompting her to drop the story.
    • Middle:
      • External: Thomson’s manipulations make Evelyn doubt her own evidence. A key witness disappears. Her newspaper faces legal threats.
      • Internal: She’s forced to consider collaborating with a reluctant, idealistic young intern (forcing her to confront her distrust). She almost compromises her journalistic integrity due to external pressure, leading to a crisis of conscience.
    • Climax:
      • External: Evelyn confronts Thomson live on air with irrefutable evidence, but he has an immediate, powerful counter-attack planned.
      • Internal: Evelyn, having learned to trust and accept help from her intern, presents a unified front. She overcomes her fear of personal exposure and vulnerability, knowing the truth is more important.

4. The “Yes, And…” / “No, But…” Method for Escalation

This fundamental improv principle is gold for plotting conflict. Every time your protagonist achieves a small victory (“Yes, And…”) or suffers a setback (“No, But…”), it should immediately lead to a new, escalating conflict.

  • “Yes, And…”: The protagonist gets a win, but it creates a new, bigger problem. They solve one mystery, and it uncovers an even deeper conspiracy.
    • Concrete Example: Evelyn gets a crucial piece of evidence… Yes, And now Thomson knows she’s close and directly threatens her career and reputation.
  • “No, But…”: The protagonist faces a defeat, but it opens a new avenue, reveals a critical weakness, or forces them to rethink their strategy.
    • Concrete Example: Evelyn’s key source is silenced… No, But the silence itself reveals the extreme lengths Thomson will go to, proving the scale of his corruption and making Evelyn even more determined.

This method prevents the story from becoming stagnant. Every scene should contribute to the rising action of conflict.

5. Integrate Subplots with Purposeful Conflict

Every subplot should either directly feed the main conflict, highlight a different facet of the main conflict, or explore a supporting character’s internal struggle that mirrors the protagonist’s. Subplots aren’t distractions; they are additional layers of conflict.

  • Actionable Step: For each subplot, ask:
    • What is the specific conflict within it?
    • How does this conflict complicate or enhance the main plot?
    • How does it reveal more about the characters involved?
    • Does its resolution affect the main conflict?
  • Example (Evelyn):
    • Subplot: The intern, Liam, is struggling with his own family expectations to pursue a more stable career, despite his passion for journalism.
    • Conflict: Liam vs. his family’s expectations (external & internal).
    • Complication/Enhancement: Liam’s struggles mirror Evelyn’s need to abandon her cynical solitary approach. His idealism challenges her jadedness. His family pressures make him hesitant to fully commit to the dangerous investigation, adding tension.
    • Resolution: When Evelyn finally trusts Liam and stands up for him, he gains the courage to defy his family and fully embrace his journalistic path, becoming an invaluable ally in the climax.

6. Leverage Reversals and Reveals

Strategic reversals (unexpected shifts in fortune) and reveals (uncoverings of hidden truths) are crucial for dynamic conflict. They keep the reader guessing and prevent the plot from feeling predictable.

  • Actionable Step: At various points, especially before the midpoint and leading into the climax, ask:
    • What’s a major development that could completely change the protagonist’s understanding of the situation?
    • What seemingly positive development could actually have a negative consequence?
    • What seemingly negative event could open up a crucial new opportunity?
    • What secret could be unveiled that radically alters relationships or motivations?
  • Concrete Example: Evelyn finally gets a source to come forward, but it’s Thomson’s own disgruntled chief of staff, who then reveals Thomson has been manipulating the press for years, including Evelyn’s own past employer. This isn’t just “corruption”; it’s a personal betrayal that adds another layer to Evelyn’s internal battle with trust.

7. The Power of “No Win” Scenarios (The Dilemma)

True conflict often presents dilemmas where every choice comes with a heavy cost. This forces characters to make difficult decisions, revealing their true nature and deepening the stakes.

  • Actionable Step: Identify moments where your protagonist faces a choice between two bad options, or where “winning” one thing means sacrificing something equally important. This highlights their values.

  • Concrete Example: Evelyn has a deadline. She has enough evidence to expose some corruption, but pushing for the full, complex story risks losing the scoop entirely and allowing Thomson to win. Publish what she has (incomplete victory) or risk everything for the full truth (potential total failure)? The choice reveals her dedication to genuine truth.

8. Ensure Consequences

Every action, every decision, every failure, and every success must have a discernible consequence. Lack of consequences deflates tension and makes conflict feel weightless.

  • Actionable Step: After a major event, ask:
    • Who is affected?
    • How are they affected?
    • What new obstacles or opportunities arise from this?
    • What is the emotional, physical, or psychological cost?
  • Concrete Example: Evelyn publishes her initial story.
    • Consequence 1: Thomson’s camp immediately launches a smear campaign against her, digging up her past professional failures. (New obstacle, external conflict).
    • Consequence 2: Her editor, initially supportive, starts to waver under pressure. (New interpersonal conflict).
    • Consequence 3: She receives anonymous threats, further isolating her. (Increased stakes, internal fear).
    • Consequence 4: However, her story also galvanizes a small group of public activists who’d also been fighting Thomson, providing an unexpected, cautious alliance. (New opportunity, but adds complexity to her trust issues).

Refine and Test Your Conflict

Plotting is an iterative process. Once you have a framework, you must test its strength.

  • The “So What?” Test: For every conflict point, ask: “So what? Why does this matter to the protagonist? Why does this matter to the story? What are the stakes?” If you can’t answer, the conflict is superficial.
  • The “Why Can’t They Just…?” Test: Imagine a reader asking this question. If there’s an obvious, easy solution your character could take to avoid the conflict, you haven’t made your obstacles strong enough or your character’s motivations compelling enough.
  • The Internal/External Alignment Check: Read through your outline specifically looking for moments where external pressures force an internal change, and where internal weaknesses hinder external progress. Ensure they are interwoven.

The Ultimate Payoff: Conflict as Catalyst for Change

The true purpose of conflict is not merely to entertain, but to drive change. Your protagonist should not be the same person at the end of the story as they were at the beginning. The crucible of conflict forges new strengths, reveals hidden truths, and ultimately, defines who they become. By meticulously crafting the engine of conflict, you don’t just plot a story; you sculpt a meaningful, transformative journey.