How to Get Email Testimonials

by

Capturing authentic, compelling testimonials via email isn’t just a nice-to-have; for writers, it’s a strategic imperative. Your words are your product, and the impact of those words, vouched for by a satisfied client, is your most powerful marketing asset. Unlike a static portfolio, a well-curated collection of glowing endorsements speaks volumes about your reliability, expertise, and the tangible results you deliver. This guide will dismantle the common hurdles to obtaining email testimonials, providing you with a step-by-step, actionable framework to consistently solicit, receive, and leverage powerful endorsements that elevate your writing career. We’ll delve beyond the superficial “just ask” and explore the psychology, timing, and precise language required to transform a wish into a flood of verifiable praise.

The Foundation: Why Email is Your Testimonial Goldmine

Before we strategize the “how,” let’s solidify the “why” email reigns supreme for testimonial acquisition. Physical letters are rare; phone calls are intrusive for a request of this nature. Email offers a non-pressuring medium that allows clients to respond at their convenience, in their own words, without feeling put on the spot.

Email’s Unique Advantages:

  • Asynchronous Convenience: Clients can craft their testimonial when they have the time and mental space, leading to more thoughtful, detailed responses.
  • Written Record: Creates a transparent, verifiable paper trail. No need to transcribe from a phone call or recall from a fleeting conversation.
  • Easy Forwarding/Sharing: Written testimonials are inherently shareable. Imagine a powerful quote from an email, instantly copy-pasted onto your website or into a proposal.
  • Professionalism: A well-crafted email request reflects your professionalism and respect for the client’s time.
  • SEO Value (Indirect): While not direct SEO, the content of testimonials often includes keywords related to your services, which can indirectly aid your personal branding and online presence.

Understanding these advantages is the first step towards embracing a robust email-based testimonial strategy.

Phase 1: Pre-Submission — Setting the Stage for Success

Testimonials don’t materialize out of thin air. They are the culmination of a positive client experience. The groundwork for a great testimonial begins long before your project concludes.

1. Deliver Exceptional Work, Consistently

This is non-negotiable. A mediocre project will never yield a glowing testimonial, regardless of how perfectly you craft your request. Focus on:

  • Clarity of Scope: Ensure both you and the client are aligned on deliverables from the outset. Surprises, particularly negative ones, erode trust.
  • Punctuality: Meeting deadlines demonstrates reliability. Even excellent writing loses its luster if delivered late.
  • Communication: Proactive updates, quick responses to queries, and clear explanations build confidence. Avoid silence. If a delay arises, communicate it immediately with a revised timeline.
  • Going the Extra Mile (Within Reason): This doesn’t mean working for free. It means delivering a tiny bit more than expected. Perhaps a quick spell-check on related content, a thoughtful suggestion for broader content strategy, or formatting the final document impeccably. These small gestures create a sense of genuine care.
  • Problem Resolution: Even excellent projects can encounter hiccups. How you handle issues – transparently, calmly, and effectively – often leaves a more lasting positive impression than a perfectly smooth journey. Turn a potential negative into an opportunity to showcase your problem-solving prowess.

Concrete Example: A writer working on a series of blog posts for a tech company not only delivered the posts on time and on brand but also proactively suggested specific internal links to existing company resources, improving SEO and user experience. This small, unrequested addition demonstrated deep engagement and value.

2. Proactive Client Communication & Feedback Loops

Don’t wait until the project ends to gauge satisfaction. Integrate feedback points throughout the project lifecycle.

  • Mid-Project Check-ins: For longer projects, send an email when a significant milestone is reached: “Just wanted to check in now that we’ve completed the first two chapters. Is everything aligning with your expectations so far? Your feedback at this stage is invaluable to ensure we’re on the right track.”
  • Open Channels: Make it easy for clients to voice concerns. Explicitly state your availability and preferred communication method.
  • Listen Actively: When feedback comes, listen to understand, not to defend. If a client expresses a minor dissatisfaction, address it head-on and demonstrate your responsiveness. This proactive approach prevents small issues from festering into large ones.

Concrete Example: A client mentioned a slight concern about the tone in an early draft of their website copy. The writer immediately scheduled a brief call, clarified the nuances of the brand voice, and resubmitted a revised section within hours, turning a potential speed bump into an affirmation of their attentiveness.

3. Identify Your Advocates: Who to Ask

Not every client is a testimonial candidate. Focus your energy on those most likely to provide glowing feedback.

  • Clients who express direct praise: “This is fantastic!” “Exactly what I needed.” “You nailed it.” These are golden opportunities.
  • Clients who re-hire you: Repeat business is the ultimate endorsement.
  • Clients who referred you to others: If they’re already talking about you, they’re likely willing to write about you.
  • Clients whose projects yielded measurable success: If your content directly contributed to increased sales, leads, or engagement, that’s powerful.
  • Clients who are generally enthusiastic and communicative: These are often the easiest to work with and the most generous with their praise.

Avoid: Clients who were consistently difficult, expressed significant dissatisfaction, or whose projects ended on a less-than-positive note. A non-testimonial is better than a lukewarm or negative one.

Phase 2: The Art of the Ask — Crafting Your Email Request

The timing and wording of your testimonial request are paramount. This isn’t a generic form letter; it’s a personalized invitation to share success.

1. Timing is Everything: When to Send the Request

Send the request when the positive experience is fresh in their minds and the value you provided is most apparent.

  • Immediately Post-Project Completion/Delivery: Ideally, within 24-72 hours of delivering the final approved work. This is when their excitement and satisfaction are at their peak.
  • After Achieving Measurable Results: If your content contributed to a launch or a campaign that saw success, wait for that success to materialize, then leverage it. “Congratulations on the amazing launch – the new product descriptions really seem to be resonating!” then transition to the request.
  • Upon Re-Engagement/New Project Kick-off: If a client comes back for more work, that’s a clear signal of satisfaction. This is a natural point to ask for a testimonial about the previous successful collaboration.

Avoid: Asking too early (before they’ve seen the full value) or too late (when they’ve moved on and the project is a distant memory).

2. Subject Line Mastery: Open Rates and Clarity

Your subject line must be professional, clear, and intriguing enough to warrant an open.

  • Be Direct and Respectful:
    • “Quick Question / Testimonial Request – [Your Name]”
    • “Feedback on [Project Name] & Quick Request”
    • “Following Up: [Project Name] & Your Valuable Feedback”
    • “A Quick Ask Regarding Our Project”
  • Avoid: “URGENT TESTIMONIAL!” or vague subjects like “Hello.”

Concrete Example: For a website content project, a great subject line could be: “Following Up: Your New Website Content & A Small Request.”

3. The Anatomy of a Perfect Testimonial Request Email

This email needs to be personal, precise, and polite. It guides the client without being overly prescriptive.

a. Express Gratitude & Recap the Success

Start by thanking them for the collaboration and briefly reminding them of the positive experience or outcome. This sets a positive tone.

  • “Hope you’re having a great week! I truly enjoyed working with you on [Project Name] and it was a pleasure crafting the [specific deliverable, e.g., blog posts, website copy, sales page content].”
  • “I’m so pleased with how the [Project Name] turned out, and I really value the opportunity to have collaborated on it.”
  • “It was a fantastic experience helping you [achieve specific goal, e.g., launch your new product, develop your brand voice, connect with your audience].”

b. State Your Purpose Clearly (The Ask)

Be upfront about why you’re reaching out. Don’t beat around the bush.

  • “To help others understand the value I offer, I’m working to gather a few testimonials from clients who’ve had a positive experience working with me.”
  • “Client feedback is incredibly important for my business, and I’d be absolutely thrilled if you’d be willing to share a brief testimonial about our collaboration.”
  • “Would you be open to providing a short testimonial about your experience working with me on [Project Name]?”

c. Make it Easy: Provide Prompts & Examples

This is crucial. Many people struggle with what to write. Give them a framework without putting words in their mouth.

Suggest Specific Areas to Cover:

  • What specific problem did I help you solve?
  • What was the most valuable aspect of our collaboration?
  • What results did you see? (e.g., increased engagement, clearer messaging, time saved)
  • What did you appreciate most about my process or communication?
  • Would you recommend my services, and if so, to whom?

Offer a Template (Optional, but effective):

  • “Here are a few questions you might consider, but please feel free to phrase it however feels natural to you:”
    • What specific challenge were you facing that led you to hire me?
    • How did my [writing service, e.g., website copywriting, content strategy] help address that challenge?
    • What was the most beneficial outcome or result you experienced?
    • What did you enjoy most about our working relationship?
  • Provide a Length Guideline: “Just a few sentences or a short paragraph would be perfect!” This reduces perceived effort.

Offer to Draft a Testimonial (Controversial but Effective for Busy Clients):

  • “I understand you’re incredibly busy, so if it’s easier, I’d be happy to draft a short sentence or two based on our project for your approval. Please just let me know if that’s something that would be helpful.”
  • Use this sparingly and with caution. It can feel less authentic if not handled deftly. Always present it as a time-saving option, and ensure they have full editorial control.

d. Explain How You’ll Use It (Transparency)

Build trust by explaining where the testimonial will be used.

  • “Your words would be incredibly helpful for my website and potentially in future proposals.”
  • “I’d love to feature your testimonial on my portfolio page and in case studies.”
  • “With your permission, I’d like to share it on my professional website and potentially on LinkedIn.”

e. Call to Action & Desired Format

Make it clear what you want them to do.

  • “If you’re able to, please just reply to this email with your testimonial.”
  • “Simply hit reply with your thoughts when you have a moment.”
  • “No need to overthink it—just a few honest lines are incredibly valuable.”

f. Professional Closing & Gratitude

Reinforce your appreciation.

  • “Thank you so much again for your time and consideration.”
  • “Warm regards,”
  • “Sincerely,”

Full Email Template Example:

Subject: Following Up: Your New Article & A Small Request

Hi [Client Name],

I hope you’re having a great week!

It was a true pleasure collaborating with you on the recent article for [Client Company/Publication Name]. I really enjoyed diving into [specific topic or aspect of the project] and I’m very pleased with how the final piece turned out.

To help others understand the results and experience of working with me, I’m gathering a few testimonials to feature on my website and in future client proposals.

Would you be open to providing a short testimonial about your experience working with me on this project? Perhaps focusing on:

  • What specific challenge were you facing that led you to hire a writer?
  • How did the article help address that challenge or meet your goals?
  • What did you appreciate most about my writing process or communication?

Just a few sentences or a short paragraph would be perfect! Your feedback is incredibly valuable.

If you’re able to, please just reply to this email with your testimonial.

Thank you so much for your time and consideration.

Warm regards,

[Your Name]
[Your Website/LinkedIn URL (Optional)]

4. Personalization Over Automation

Every request should feel personal, not like a mass email. Refer to specific project details. Mention a specific positive interaction. This reinforces that you value their individual experience.

Phase 3: Post-Submission — Leveraging and Maintaining Testimonials

Getting the testimonial is only half the battle. How you use it and manage the process is equally important.

1. The Thank You Email: A Crucial Follow-Up

Always, always thank them promptly after receiving the testimonial.

  • Express genuine gratitude: “Thank you so much for taking the time to send this over. I truly appreciate your kind words!”
  • Confirm usage: “Your testimonial is wonderful, and I’m thrilled to feature it on my website. I’ll be sure to let you know once it’s live.”
  • Offer a reciprocal gesture (optional): If appropriate, offer to write a brief LinkedIn recommendation for them, or share their recent news with your network. This further builds goodwill.

Concrete Example: “Thank you so much for the fantastic testimonial, [Client Name]! I genuinely appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. I’ll be adding it to my website next week. If there’s anything I can ever do to support your work or share your successes on LinkedIn, please don’t hesitate to let me know.”

2. Attribution: Getting it Right

Accuracy and permission are key.

  • Name: Always include their full name.
  • Title/Company: Essential for credibility. “John Doe, Marketing Director at Acme Corp.” adds more weight than just “John Doe.”
  • Photo (Optional but powerful): Politely ask if they’d be willing to share a professional headshot to accompany their testimonial. “Would you also be comfortable sharing a professional headshot to accompany your testimonial on my site? It really helps to put a face to the name.” If yes, specify image requirements (e.g., JPEG, high-res). If no, respect that.

3. Where to Display Your Testimonials

Make them visible and accessible.

  • Dedicated Testimonial Page: A single page on your website dedicated to showcasing all your glowing reviews.
  • Homepage: A rotating carousel or select few “best of” testimonials on your homepage immediately builds trust.
  • Service Pages: Relevant testimonials directly on the service page they relate to (e.g., website copy testimonials on your “Website Copywriting” service page).
  • Proposals/Pitches: Handpick the most relevant testimonials to include in bespoke proposals for new clients.
  • Email Signature: A compelling short quote with a link to your full testimonial page.
  • Social Media: Share snippets on platforms like LinkedIn, perhaps with a link to the full testimonial or accompanying case study.
  • LinkedIn Profile: The “Recommendations” section is specifically for this.

4. Refresh and Re-Solicit (The Long Game)

Testimonials have a shelf life. Keep your collection fresh and relevant.

  • Annually/Bi-Annually: Review your testimonials. Are they still relevant? Do they speak to your current services?
  • Re-Engage Satisfied Clients: If you haven’t worked with a client in a while but the experience was positive, and they’ve since achieved more success, consider a polite follow-up for an updated testimonial. “Hope you’re well! I was just thinking about the [Project Name] we worked on last year. I know you’ve been doing some incredible things since then. Would you consider providing a quick updated testimonial about the value that initial project still provides for you now?”
  • New Services: As your writing services evolve, seek testimonials that speak directly to your new offerings.

Beyond the Basics: Advanced Testimonial Tactics

1. Video Testimonials (The Holy Grail)

While this guide focuses on email, the ultimate testimonial is often video. If a client provides an outstanding email testimonial and seems enthusiastic, consider: “Would you ever be open to a very brief (2-3 minute) video testimonial? Even a quick recording on your phone would be amazing. No pressure at all, of course!” Offer to send questions to guide them.

2. Case Studies: Testimonials on Steroids

A case study takes a testimonial and builds a narrative around it. It details the client’s problem, your solution, and the specific results. An email testimonial often forms the core of a powerful case study.

  • Use the testimonial as a headline or key quote.
  • Expand on the “why they hired you” and “how you solved it” that the testimonial might briefly mention.
  • Quantify results whenever possible.

3. The Testimonial Strategy Document

For those who are serious about scaling their writing business, create a simple internal document:

  • Client Name:
  • Project Name:
  • Date Completed:
  • Satisfaction Score (Internal): 1-5
  • Testimonial Requested Date:
  • Testimonial Received Date:
  • Key Quotes (for easy access):
  • Usage Notes: (e.g., “Good for website copy page,” “Relevant for SaaS clients”)

This structured approach ensures no opportunity is missed and you have a ready database of powerful praise.

Troubleshooting Common Obstacles

Even with the perfect strategy, you might encounter bumps.

1. No Response

  • Wait a few days: Life happens. Don’t immediately send a second email.
  • Send a polite follow-up: If no response after 5-7 business days: “Hi [Client Name], Just wanted to gently follow up on my previous email regarding a testimonial. Absolutely no pressure at all if you’re too busy, but I just wanted to make sure it didn’t get lost in the shuffle. Your feedback truly means a lot. Thanks!”
  • Offer the drafted option: If you didn’t do so initially, this is a good point to offer to draft something for their approval.
  • Move on: If after two attempts there’s no response, accept it and focus on other clients.

2. Vague or General Testimonials

Sometimes, despite your prompts, you receive something generic like, “John is a good writer.”

  • Thank them first, always.
  • Politely ask for specifics: “Thank you so much, [Client Name]! I really appreciate your feedback. Would you mind expanding a little bit on what specifically made me a ‘good writer’ for you? Perhaps what problem I helped you solve, or what really stood out about our collaboration? Even a sentence or two more would be incredibly helpful.”
  • Suggest an edit yourself (with permission): “Would you be open to me tweaking it slightly to integrate [specific project detail/result] just to make it more impactful for my website? I will, of course, send it back for your final approval before using it.”

3. Client Requests Payment

This is rare, but if it happens, politely decline. Testimonials should be authentic endorsements, not paid advertisements. “I appreciate you considering sharing your experience. My testimonial policy is built on authentic client feedback, and I don’t typically compensate for endorsements. Thank you for understanding.”

Conclusion

Obtaining powerful email testimonials is a strategic process, not a chance occurrence. It begins with exceptional service, cultivates through mindful communication, and culminates in a precisely worded, well-timed request. By understanding the psychology of the ask, providing clear guidance, and offering a seamless pathway for clients to share their positive experiences, you will build an invaluable repository of social proof. These authentic endorsements are more than just flattering words; they are the bedrock for attracting new clients, commanding better rates, and solidifying your reputation as a trusted, results-driven writer. Implement this framework, refine it with each interaction, and watch as your reservoir of compelling client voices becomes your most potent marketing tool.