How to Submit to Agents: The Right Way

by

The literary agent is the gatekeeper, the champion, the architect of a writing career. For aspiring authors, securing representation feels like a monumental, often insurmountable, task. The publishing industry, in its intricate dance of creativity and commerce, relies heavily on these discerning professionals to scout talent, negotiate deals, and navigate the complex journey from manuscript to bookstore shelf. This guide cuts through the noise, offering an exhaustive, actionable roadmap for submitting to agents – not just a way, but the right way. It’s about precision, professionalism, and strategic self-advocacy, ensuring your manuscript doesn’t just land in an agent’s inbox, but genuinely captures their attention.

Understanding the Landscape: Why Agents Matter (And What They Do)

Before you hit “send,” you must grasp the fundamental role of a literary agent. They are not merely readers; they are business partners. An agent’s primary function is to sell your book to a publishing house. This involves:

  • Market Knowledge: Knowing which editors acquire what, understanding current trends, and identifying the best fit for your manuscript.
  • Negotiation Expertise: Securing the best possible advance, royalty rates, and subsidiary rights (film, foreign, audio, etc.).
  • Career Guidance: Advising on future projects, navigating contract intricacies, and acting as a buffer between you and your publisher.
  • Advocacy: Championing your work, troubleshooting issues, and ensuring your interests are protected throughout the publishing process.

Submitting directly to major publishing houses is rarely an option, as most only accept agented submissions. Therefore, the agent becomes your essential first step towards traditional publication.

Before You Start: The Non-Negotiable Pre-Submission Checklist

Patience is not just a virtue; it’s a strategic necessity in the world of publishing. Rushing this initial phase guarantees failure.

Your Manuscript: Polished to a Diamond Sheen

This is the single most critical element. No query letter, no matter how brilliant, can compensate for a flawed manuscript.

  1. Completion: Your manuscript must be 100% finished. Not 90%, not “almost done,” but complete. Agents will ask for the full manuscript if interested, and you must be ready.
  2. Revision Cycles: A first draft is never the final draft. You should have undertaken multiple rounds of self-revision, focusing on plot, character, pacing, dialogue, theme, and world-building (if applicable).
  3. Beta Readers: Solicit feedback from trusted, critical readers who understand your genre. These aren’t cheerleaders; they’re your first line of defense against blind spots. Ask specific questions: “Where did the pacing drag?” “Did this character’s motivation make sense?”
  4. Professional Editing (Optional but Recommended): While an agent will help with editorial feedback, a professional copyedit or developmental edit can elevate your manuscript from good to exceptional, demonstrating your commitment and professionalism. This is an investment, but a worthwhile one for serious authors. If you can’t afford it, rely heavily on meticulous self-editing and astute beta feedback.

Genre Identification and Word Count Adherence

Understanding your genre is paramount. It’s not just a category; it dictates audience expectations, market trends, and agent specialties.

  • Be Specific: Don’t just say “fantasy”; is it epic fantasy, urban fantasy, YA fantasy, grimdark?
  • Target Word Count: Every genre has an expected word count range. Deviating significantly (e.g., a 200,000-word YA novel) signals a lack of market awareness.
    • Commercial Fiction (Thrillers, Mysteries, Romance): 70,000 – 90,000 words
    • Literary Fiction: 60,000 – 100,000 words
    • Fantasy/Sci-Fi: 90,000 – 120,000 words (can sometimes go higher, but be cautious)
    • Young Adult (YA): 50,000 – 80,000 words
    • Middle Grade (MG): 20,000 – 50,000 words
    • Picture Books: 500 – 1,000 words (query with full text, no need for illustration notes unless critical)
    • Non-Fiction: Submit with a detailed book proposal, not a full manuscript. This is an entirely different beast requiring its own dedicated guide. (This guide focuses on fiction.)

Comps (Comparative Titles): Your Manuscript’s Peers

Comps aren’t just “books you like.” They are recent (published within the last 3-5 years) titles that share a similar target audience, genre, or blend of elements as your manuscript, but aren’t too similar.

  • Purpose: To help the agent quickly position your book in the market. It tells them: “If you like X and Y, you’ll love my book.”
  • Avoid: Bestsellers from decades ago (e.g., “It’s like Harry Potter meets Lord of the Rings”) or obscure titles no one has heard of. Also, avoid comparing your book to classics like “It’s a modern Great Gatsby.”
  • Format: Typically two or three titles. “My book has the emotional depth of [Comp 1] combined with the high-stakes plot of [Comp 2], with a unique twist that…”

The Essential Submission Package: Crafting Your Calling Card

Your submission package is an agent’s first impression of your writing. It must be impeccable.

The Query Letter: Your One-Page Sales Pitch

This is arguably the most challenging piece of writing you’ll ever undertake. It’s a single-page document (300-400 words max) that must entice an agent to request more.

  1. Personalized Opening (The Hook):
    • Address the Agent by Name: “Dear Ms. Smith” or “Dear Mr. Jones.” Never a generic “To Whom It May Concern.”
    • Specific Reason for Querying: This demonstrates you’ve done your research. “I’m querying you because of your stated interest in dark academia on [Agency Website/MSWL], and I believe my 85,000-word adult novel, The Crimson Key, aligns perfectly with your list.” Or, “I saw on Manuscript Wish List (MSWL) that you’re seeking high-concept thrillers, and I think my novel, The Silent Choir, would be a great fit.”
    • Avoid Flattery Over Substance: Don’t go on and on about how much you love their agency. Get to the point.
  2. The Hook/Logline (1-2 Sentences):
    • A concise, compelling pitch that introduces your protagonist, their core conflict, and the stakes. Think movie pitch.
    • Example (Thriller): “When a disgraced detective finds his estranged daughter implicated in a ritualistic murder replicating ancient myths, he must confront his own demons and the city’s hidden occult underworld before she becomes the killer’s next sacrifice.”
  3. The Blurb/Mini-Synopsis (2-3 paragraphs):
    • This is not a full synopsis. It’s the back-cover copy of your book. It introduces the inciting incident, the main character’s goal, the primary obstacles, and the escalating stakes.
    • Do NOT give away the ending. Leave the agent wanting to know what happens next.
    • Focus on plot, character, and conflict. Narrative drive.
    • Example (YA contemporary fantasy): “Seventeen-year-old Luna has always lived in the shadow of her older sister, a prodigy of forbidden magic. But when her sister vanishes, leaving behind a cryptic constellation map, Luna must embark on a dangerous journey into the hidden magic communities of New York City, where ancient rivalries and a looming prophecy threaten to tear her world–and her family–apart. With time running out, Luna must decide if she’s willing to embrace a power she never wanted, or lose her sister forever to a vengeful goddess.”
  4. The Bio (1 paragraph):
    • Keep it concise and relevant.
    • Publishing Credits: List any previous publishing successes (short stories in literary magazines, articles, awards, etc.). If you have none, that’s fine. State that this is your debut novel.
    • Relevant Life Experience: If your life experience uniquely informs your manuscript (e.g., a former FBI agent writing a crime thriller), mention it.
    • Platform (For Non-Fiction or if Relevant for Fiction): If you have a significant online presence, large social media following, or specific expertise that enhances your marketability, include it (e.g., “I host the popular podcast ‘Ancient Mysteries Revealed,’ with over 50,000 listeners, where I often discuss themes found in The Crimson Key“). For most fiction, this is less critical unless you have a truly massive following.
    • Avoid: Personal details unrelated to your writing, lengthy personal anecdotes, or discussing your writing routine.
  5. The Mechanics/Closing:
    • Word Count & Genre: Reiterate your book’s title, genre, and word count.
    • Standard Closing: “Thank you for your time and consideration.”
    • Professional Sign-Off: “Sincerely,” “Regards,” or “All the Best,” followed by your full name, email address, phone number, and website/social media links (if applicable and professional).
    • Attachment/Paste: If you are attaching material, state what you are attaching (e.g., “Per your guidelines, I’ve attached the first 10 pages and a synopsis.”). If pasting, state that.
    • Query Manager/Online Forms: Many agencies use online query submission forms (QueryManager, QueryTracker) which often dictate formatting. Always follow their instructions precisely.

The Synopsis: The Full Story, Abridged (1-2 Pages)

The synopsis tells the WHOLE story, including the ending. It demonstrates your command of plot, character arc, and pacing. It’s not marketing copy; it’s a structural outline.

  • Purpose: To show the agent you know how to tell a complete story, resolve conflict, and bring your narrative to a satisfying conclusion.
  • Format: Single-spaced, 12pt Times New Roman or similar. No more than two pages (for a typical novel).
  • Content:
    • Protagonist & Inciting Incident: Introduce your main character and the event that kicks off the story.
    • Rising Action & Subplots: Detail the major plot points, key conflicts, character development, and important subplots.
    • Climax: Describe the peak of the conflict.
    • Resolution: Explain how the story ends, including the fate of major characters and the thematic closure.
  • Tone: Professional and objective. Avoid flowery language or hyperbole. Focus on clarity and conciseness, making sure every sentence serves a purpose.
  • Example Segments (for a murder mystery):
    • Beginning: “Detective Alex Vance, haunted by a past case, is plunged back into the city’s underbelly when the body of celebrated artist, Beatrice Thorne, is found staged in a macabre tableau. Initial evidence points to an unknown cult.”
    • Middle: “As Alex delves deeper, he uncovers a network of art forgers and illicit antique dealers, forcing him to confront Lieutenant Davies, his estranged mentor, who appears to be covering up key information. Alex’s investigation takes a personal turn when his sister, an art historian, becomes a target, revealing Thorne’s secret research into an ancient artifact linked to the cult.”
    • End: “The climax unfolds at the abandoned cathedral, where Alex confronts Davies, realizing his mentor was manipulated by the cult’s true leader, Thorne’s former assistant. Alex disarms the bomb, saves his sister, and exposes the cult, but the artifact vanishes, leaving a chilling hint of future threats while Alex begins to heal from his past.”

Sample Pages: Your Writing in Action

This is where your manuscript’s quality truly shines. These are typically the first 10-50 pages, as specified by the agent’s submission guidelines.

  • Flawless Prose: No typos, grammatical errors, or stylistic inconsistencies. This should be your absolute best, most polished work.
  • Engaging Opening: The first few pages are crucial. They must hook the reader, establish voice, introduce character, and hint at conflict. If your story truly begins on page 50, you need to rewrite your opening.
  • Formatting: Standard manuscript format: 12pt Times New Roman or Courier New, double-spaced, 1-inch margins, page numbers in the header. Your last name, title of manuscript, and page number should be on every page.

The Strategic Submission Process: Research, Target, Track

Blindly submitting to every agent you find is signing your own rejection slip. A highly targeted approach is key.

Agent Research: The Deep Dive

This is where you prevent shotgunning your submissions.

  1. AgentQuery.com & QueryTracker.net: These are invaluable databases for finding agents, checking their submission guidelines, tracking their responsiveness, and even seeing what others are submitting. QueryTracker’s premium membership offers robust search filters and statistics.
  2. Publisher’s Marketplace: Subscription-based, but excellent for seeing what agents are actually selling, the types of deals they’re making, and the editors they work with. This tells you if an agent is active and successful in your genre.
  3. Agency Websites: Crucial for current submission guidelines, agent wishlists (MSWL), and the specific types of projects they are looking for (or explicitly not looking for). Agents often update their wishlists regularly.
  4. Manuscript Wish List (MSWL.com): A fantastic resource where agents post specific genres, tropes, and themes they are seeking.
  5. Social Media (Twitter/X, Bluesky, Mastodon): Many agents are active on social media, discussing their interests, sharing tips, and participating in pitch contests. Follow them to get a feel for their personality and preferences.
  6. Literary Conferences & Workshops: Attending these events allows for face-to-face interactions, pitch sessions (if offered), and networking that can lead to direct submissions.

Building Your Target List (The A-List, B-List Method)

Don’t just pick agents randomly. Create a tiered list.

  • A-List (Top Priority – 5-10 Agents): These are the agents who are a perfect fit. Their wish list explicitly matches your manuscript, they have an impressive track record in your genre, and there’s something about their profile that genuinely resonates. You will spend the most time personalizing queries to these agents.
  • B-List (Next Priority – 10-15 Agents): Good fits, but perhaps less direct. They represent your genre, but maybe less frequently, or their specific “wants” aren’t quite as tailored to your project.
  • C-List (Wider Net – 10-20 Agents): Agents who represent your broader genre but aren’t necessarily asking for your specific sub-genre or trope. You’ll cast a slightly wider net here only after exhausting your A and B lists.

Key Rule: Never query more than 5-7 agents at a time. This allows you to learn from rejections. If agents consistently reject your query or opening pages, it’s a strong signal that something needs to be revised. If you send out 50 queries at once, you lose this crucial feedback loop.

Tailoring Your Query: Precision Over Volume

Every query must be personalized. A generic query shouts, “I didn’t research you!”

  • Specific References: “I saw on your MSWL that you’re looking for feminist historical fiction, which makes The Gilded Cage a perfect fit.” Or, “I particularly enjoyed your recent sale of The Midnight Daughter to [Publisher] as its blend of mystery and folklore is something I also explore in my novel, The Whispering Woods.”
  • Show, Don’t Just Tell: Don’t just say you’re a good writer; make your query letter itself demonstrate your clear, concise, and compelling writing.

The Submission Process (Actual Sending)

  1. Follow Guidelines EXACTLY: If an agent says to paste your query and first 5 pages into the email body, do not attach anything. If they say 10 pages as a Word document attachment, send that. Deviating is an immediate red flag.
  2. Professional Email Address: Use a professional-sounding email address (e.g., yourname@email.com).
  3. Clear Subject Line: Usually, “Query: [Your Book Title] – [Your Name]” or as specified by the agent.
  4. Attachments: If required, ensure file names are professional (e.g., “YourName_ManuscriptTitle_Synopsis.pdf”). Use PDF for synopses and query letters if allowed, as it preserves formatting. Sample pages are typically requested as Word documents.

Tracking Your Submissions: The Rejection Management System

You need a system for tracking. A simple spreadsheet works wonders.

  • Columns:
    • Agent Name
    • Agency Name
    • Date Sent
    • Material Sent (Query only, Q+10 pages, Q+Synopsis, Full)
    • Response Type (Rejection, Full Request, Partial Request, Pass)
    • Date of Response
    • Notes (e.g., “personalized rejection,” “form rejection,” “feedback given,” “followed up”)
    • Status (Active, Closed, Revise Manuscript)
  • Why Track?
    • Avoid Doubles: You’ll never accidentally query the same agent twice with the same manuscript.
    • Follow-Up: Know when it’s appropriate to nudge (some guidelines give a period, e.g., 6-8 weeks for query, 8-12 weeks for full request). Always check guidelines for nudging policy—many agents explicitly state “no nudges.”
    • Identify Patterns: If you get 20 rejections on your query but never a request for pages, your query might be the problem. If you get many partial/full requests but then rejections, your opening pages or the manuscript itself might need work.
    • Manage Expectations: Rejection is part of the process. Seeing your tracking spreadsheet fill with “rejection” isn’t a sign of failure, but a sign of trying.

The Waiting Game: Patience, Persistence, and Professionalism

Once you’ve sent your queries, the hardest part begins: waiting.

Understanding Response Times

Agents are inundated. They receive hundreds, if not thousands, of queries a month.

  • Query Responses: Can range from days to 6-12 weeks, sometimes longer. Many are form rejections.
  • Partial/Full Manuscript Responses: If an agent requests more, expect to wait even longer, 3-6 months is common, sometimes up to a year. They fit reading into an already packed schedule.
  • No Response: Many agents consider no response a pass/rejection after a certain timeframe (often 12 weeks for queries, 6 months for fulls). Check their guidelines.

Nudging: When and How (If Permitted)

A “nudge” is a polite reminder.

  • Check Guidelines First: Has the agent explicitly stated “no nudges”? If so, don’t.
  • When to Nudge: If past their stated response time, or if you receive an offer of representation from another agent.
  • How to Nudge (Offer): If you receive an offer of representation, immediately inform all other agents who have your full or partial manuscript. This is standard procedure and often dramatically speeds up their reading. Email them with a subject line like: “Offer of Representation – [Your Book Title] – [Your Name]”. In the email, state who offered, when, and the deadline for their offer. Give other agents 1-2 weeks to respond.
  • How to Nudge (No Offer): If no offer, simply a very brief, polite email: “Dear [Agent Name], I hope this email finds you well. I queried [Your Book Title] on [Date]. I just wanted to gently check in on the status of my submission. Thank you for your time and continued consideration. Sincerely, [Your Name].” Keep it short, one follow-up only.

Handling Rejection: An Inevitable Part of the Journey

Rejection isn’t personal; it’s professional. It means your manuscript wasn’t the right fit for that specific agent at that specific time.

  • Expect It: Embrace the reality that rejections will far outnumber requests.
  • Learn from It:
    • Form Rejections: Often the “death by a thousand cuts” rejections for a query or first pages. Little to learn here, as they’re generic.
    • Personalized Rejections: These are golden. Even if brief, they often provide insight. “Loved the concept, but the pacing dragged in the second act.” This is a specific call to action for revision.
  • Don’t Argue: Never, ever argue with an agent’s rejection. It’s unprofessional and will blacklist you.
  • Keep Writing: The best way to deal with rejection is to start your next project. It shows resilience and professional intent. An agent who passed on your first book might be interested in your second.

Full Request: A Glimmer of Hope

An agent requesting your full manuscript is a significant achievement. It means your query and opening pages hooked them.

  • Don’t Celebrate Too Soon: While exciting, it’s not an offer. The agent is now evaluating the entire story.
  • Be Ready: Have your full manuscript perfectly formatted and ready to send immediately.
  • Patience (Again): The wait time for a full read is often much longer than a query read.

After the Offer: Due Diligence and Making the Right Choice

An offer of representation is a monumental moment, but it’s not the end of the journey; it’s the beginning of the next critical phase.

The “Call”: What to Expect

If an agent is interested, they’ll schedule a call. This is your interview with them, but also their interview with you.

  • What they’ll discuss:
    • Why they loved your manuscript.
    • Their vision for your book and career.
    • Editorial feedback they might have (this is common).
    • Their approach to submission, marketing, and the overall process.
    • Their agency structure, commission rates (standard is 15% for domestic, 20% for foreign, 20% for film—negotiation is not common here), and contract terms.
  • What YOU should ask:
    • Editorial Approach: “What kind of editorial feedback do you envision for this manuscript?”
    • Submission Strategy: “Which editors/publishing houses do you plan to submit to first?” “What’s your typical submission process?”
    • Communication: “How do you prefer to communicate, and what’s your typical response time?”
    • Career Vision: “How do you see my career developing over the next 5-10 years?” “Are you interested in my other project ideas?”
    • Referrals: “Would it be possible to speak with one or two of your current clients/authors about their experience?” (A good agent will readily agree).
    • Terms: “Can you walk me through your agency agreement?”
    • Marketing/Platform: “What are your expectations for my author platform, and how do you support authors in building theirs?”

Due Diligence: Researching the Agent

Just because they offered, doesn’t mean they’re the right agent.

  1. Check Publisher’s Marketplace: See their recent deals. Are they selling books in your genre? To reputable publishers?
  2. Speak to Other Clients: This is invaluable. Ask about communication, editorial support, their selling process, and overall satisfaction.
  3. Consult Literary Lawyers (Optional but Recommended for Contract Review): Before signing, consider having a publishing lawyer review the agency agreement. This is a business contract, and understanding its implications is crucial.
  4. Trust Your Gut: Do you feel good about this person? Do they seem genuinely passionate about your work? Is their vision aligned with yours?

Making Your Decision

Take your time (within the offer deadline). Don’t rush into a long-term professional relationship.

  • Consider all factors: Editorial vision, passion for your book, communication style, sales record, agency resources, and the overall “fit.”
  • Don’t Chase the Biggest Name: A less prominent agent who is passionate about your book and willing to put in the work is infinitely better than a famous agent who barely remembers your name.
  • Be Professional: Whether accepting or declining, communicate clearly and professionally. Thank agents who offered and those who read your full, even if you’re declining.

The Long Game: Perseverance and Continuous Improvement

Securing an agent is a massive step, but it’s part of a marathon, not a sprint.

  • Keep Writing: Agents want career authors, not one-hit wonders. Be working on your next project.
  • Stay Professional: Publisher relationships, future deals, and your reputation depend on it.
  • Embrace the Partnership: Your agent is your advocate. Work with them. Trust their expertise but also communicate your own vision and concerns.

The journey to publication is fraught with challenges, but by approaching agent submissions with meticulous preparation, strategic research, unwavering professionalism, and boundless patience, you dramatically increase your chances of finding the right champion for your work. This isn’t just about sending an email; it’s about initiating a career, one perfectly crafted query at a time.