How to Write Your Own Rules

by

The blank page, for a writer, is both a haven and a battleground. It promises infinite possibility while simultaneously presenting the daunting truth that you are the architect of your own literary universe. No publisher, editor, or online guru can definitively tell you how your voice should sound, how your stories should unfold, or how your career should progress. These are the rules you must forge for yourself. This isn’t about rebellion for its own sake, but about the profound, liberating act of self-definition that allows creativity to flourish unhindered. This definitive guide will equip you with the strategies, mindset, and practical tools to write your own rules, transforming your writing practice from a reactive endeavor into a proactive, powerful force.

The Imperative of Self-Authored Directives: Why “Their Rules” Don’t Work

Before we dive into the how, let’s understand the why. For too long, writers have been implicitly, and sometimes explicitly, conditioned to seek external validation and follow prescribed paths. We chase trends, ape successful authors, adhere to rigid genre conventions, and internalize industry “best practices” that may or may not serve our unique artistic vision.

The Problem with Prescribed Rules:

  • Stifled Originality: When you constantly look over your shoulder, you lose sight of your own distinct perspective. Imitation, while a useful learning tool, becomes a creative straitjacket when it’s your primary mode of operation. Your voice, the very essence of your unique contribution, gets diluted.
  • Burnout and Disillusionment: Chasing external benchmarks—whether it’s agent queries, bestseller lists, or social media metrics—without a strong internal compass inevitably leads to exhaustion. When success is measured by someone else’s ruler, you’re always playing catch-up, rarely truly satisfied.
  • Loss of Agency: Handing over the reins of your creative journey to external forces means surrendering your artistic independence. You become a cog in someone else’s machine, rather than the visionary behind your own.
  • Irrelevant Advice: What worked for one author, one genre, or one market at a specific time may be utterly useless, even detrimental, to you. Generic advice often fails to account for individual strengths, weaknesses, and aspirations. For example, a successful thriller writer’s advice on plotting might be counterproductive for a literary fiction author focused on character studies.

Writing your own rules isn’t about ignoring all advice; it’s about filtering all advice through the lens of your own intentional purpose. It’s about building a robust internal framework that supports your growth, your vision, and your definition of success.

Deconstructing Your Writing Universe: Identifying Areas for Rule-Making

To write your own rules, you first need to understand the vast landscape of your writing life. It’s not just about what you write, but how you write, why you write, and how you navigate the writing world. We’ll break down these areas into actionable categories.

1. The Creative Process: Forging Your Artistic Blueprint

This is the core of your rule-making. How do you approach the act of creation itself?

  • Rule for Idea Generation: Do you wait for inspiration to strike, or do you actively cultivate it?
    • Old Rule (Implicit): Ideas come from flashes of brilliance, usually unbidden.
    • New Rule (Self-Authored): “My ideas are cultivated through deliberate observation and structured brainstorming. I dedicate 30 minutes each day to ‘idea foraging,’ reviewing news, personal experiences, and unusual concepts, and jotting down at least three potential story sparks.”
    • Example: Instead of hoping for a novel idea, you might decree: “I will carry a small notebook and pen everywhere. Any time I observe an unusual human interaction, an interesting turn of phrase, or a peculiar object, I will immediately jot it down, labeling it as ‘Story Seed.'”
  • Rule for Plotting vs. Pantsing: How much structure do you need before you begin?
    • Old Rule: Good writers either meticulously outline (plotters) or spontaneously discover (pantsers). You must pick one.
    • New Rule: “My process is a hybrid. I will create a loose ‘compass outline’ – a few key turning points and character arcs – before beginning, but allow significant room for discovery and spontaneity within scenes. If I get stuck, I’ll return to my compass and plot the next three scenes.”
    • Example: For a fantasy writer: “My Rule of Worldbuilding: I will only worldbuild what is absolutely necessary for the current scene or chapter. Deep dives into ancient elven history are reserved for when a character needs that knowledge, preventing procrastination and overwhelming data dumps.”
  • Rule for Draft Zero (The Ugly Draft): What is the purpose of your initial output?
    • Old Rule: Every sentence should be polished, or at least well-formed.
    • New Rule: “My first draft is solely for getting the story down. Grammar, spelling, and elegant prose are irrelevant. Its purpose is to capture the raw narrative energy. I will not self-edit while drafting, and I will only focus on forward momentum.”
    • Concrete Action: Place a sign above your monitor: “No Perfection, Only Progress.” Or set a timer for 60 minutes and write without stopping, no backspacing allowed. These actionable steps reinforce the rule.
  • Rule for Revision: How do you approach making your work better?
    • Old Rule: Revision is about fixing mistakes.
    • New Rule: “My revision process is multi-layered. First pass: structural integrity. Second pass: character motivation and arc. Third pass: voice and prose polish. I will tackle one specific element per revision pass, never all at once.”
    • Example: “After completing a novel, my first rule of revision is ‘The Character Arc Check’: I print out the manuscript and, with a different colored highlighter for each main character, I mark every moment they make a decision, learn something, or express a core belief. This visually exposes any flat arcs or inconsistencies.”

2. The Routine and Environment: Structuring Your Writing Life

Consistency is the bedrock of a productive writing life. How do you integrate writing into your daily existence?

  • Rule for Writing Time: When and for how long do you write?
    • Old Rule: Successful writers write for X hours every day.
    • New Rule: “My prime creative window is 6 AM to 8 AM. During these hours, all notifications are muted, and I am inaccessible. If I miss this window, I commit to 30 focused minutes at another point in the day, but the morning is sacred.”
    • Example: If you’re a night owl, your rule might be: “My ‘Deep Work’ writing sessions occur between 10 PM and 1 AM, after daily distractions have subsided. I prepare my workspace and a calming beverage to signal the start of this focused period.”
  • Rule for Workspace: Where do you write, and what conditions are essential?
    • Old Rule: You need a dedicated, perfectly organized office.
    • New Rule: “My workspace must be free of visual clutter directly in my line of sight. I require natural light and a specific soundtrack (instrumental scores only, no lyrics) to signal ‘writing mode.’ If these conditions are not met, I find an alternative location rather than forcing it.”
    • Example: “Even if I’m writing in a busy coffee shop, my rule is to wear noise-canceling headphones and create a small, portable ‘focus zone’ with only my laptop and a dedicated writing app open. No social media tabs allowed.”
  • Rule for Breaks and Rest: How do you prevent burnout?
    • Old Rule: Work until you drop, then recover.
    • New Rule: “I integrate mandatory 10-minute breaks every hour of focused writing, walking away from the screen. Sundays are entirely writing-free days, dedicated to leisure and rejuvenation, ensuring I return refreshed.”
    • Concrete Action: Set a recurring alarm on your phone for a “Writing Break.” When it goes off, you must stand up and stretch, walk, or grab a drink. This creates a non-negotiable pause.
  • Rule for Procrastination: How do you circumvent resistance?
    • Old Rule: Just push through it.
    • New Rule: “When I feel resistance, my rule is the ‘Fifteen-Minute Sprint’: I commit to writing for just fifteen minutes. If after that time the words flow, I continue. If not, I pivot to a different writing-related task (research, outlining, editing an older piece) to maintain momentum without forcing it.”
    • Example: “My ‘Pre-Writing Ritual’ rule: Before I write, I spend five minutes tidying my immediate desk area and making a cup of tea. This small, consistent ritual acts as a ‘prime the pump’ action, signaling to my brain that it’s time to shift into creative mode, often circumventing inertia.”

3. The Professional Sphere: Navigating the Industry on Your Terms

This is where many writers surrender their autonomy. Writing your own rules here is about defining your path to publication, promotion, and professional development.

  • Rule for Feedback: Whose opinions truly matter, and how do you receive them?
    • Old Rule: Seek input from everyone, and try to please all critics.
    • New Rule: “I will solicit feedback from a maximum of three trusted critique partners whose understanding of my genre and goals I respect. I will listen to their insights but reserve the final decision on revisions for myself. I will never engage with unsolicited, unconstructive criticism.”
    • Example: “My ‘Feedback Filter’ rule: When I receive critique, I categorize each point into three columns: ‘Strong Yes’ (immediately actionable), ‘Consider’ (worth mulling over), and ‘No’ (does not align with my vision). I only re-read the ‘Strong Yes’ and ‘Consider’ points, preventing me from getting bogged down by extraneous feedback.”
  • Rule for Publication Pathway: How will you share your work?
    • Old Rule: Traditional publishing is the only legitimate path.
    • New Rule: “My primary goal is to reach my ideal readers. I will explore both traditional and independent publishing options, choosing the path that best aligns with my artistic vision, control over my work, and long-term career goals, rather than external prestige.”
    • Concrete Action: Define what “reach ideal readers” means for you. Is it 100 dedicated fans? 10,000 downloads? A certain number of starred reviews? Having a clear personal metric allows you to evaluate pathways objectively.
  • Rule for Promotion and Marketing: How much energy will you dedicate to self-promotion?
    • Old Rule: You must be constantly active on all social media platforms.
    • New Rule: “My promotion efforts will be focused on building genuine connections with readers through a curated newsletter and one primary social media platform (e.g., a writer’s blog or X/Twitter). I will allocate a maximum of one hour per day for these activities, ensuring they don’t detract from my writing.”
    • Example: “My ‘Authenticity in Promotion’ rule: I will only share content that genuinely excites me or offers value to my readers, rather than just chasing engagement. If it feels like a marketing chore, I won’t do it.” This rule prevents burnout from performative online presence.
  • Rule for Professional Development: How do you continue to learn and grow?
    • Old Rule: Attend every conference, buy every course.
    • New Rule: “I will invest in one new high-quality writing craft book or a targeted online course each quarter, focusing on specific skills I’m actively trying to develop (e.g., dialogue, pacing). My learning must be applied to a current project within one week.”
    • Example: “My ‘Skill Acquisition’ rule: Instead of general workshops, I will seek out focused masterclasses on my current weakest point. If I’m struggling with developing compelling antagonists, I will find a course specifically on that, rather than a general ‘How to Write a Novel’ workshop.”

4. The Mindset and Self-Care: Protecting Your Inner Writer

This area is often overlooked but is crucial for long-term sustainability. Your mental and emotional health directly impacts your creative output.

  • Rule for Dealing with Imposter Syndrome: How do you quiet the inner critic?
    • Old Rule: Ignore it, or suffer through it.
    • New Rule: “When imposter syndrome strikes, I will acknowledge the feeling without judgment, then recite my ‘Writer’s Worth’ mantra: ‘My unique perspective is inherently valuable, and my voice deserves to be heard. I am learning and growing, and every word contributes to my journey.’ Then, I will immediately return to my work.”
    • Concrete Action: Write your mantra on a sticky note and place it directly on your monitor. When the self-doubt creeps in, look at it, speak it aloud.
  • Rule for Creative Well-Being: How do you replenish your creative well?
    • Old Rule: Push harder, more writing equals more success.
    • New Rule: “I will dedicate dedicated time each week to activities that nourish my imagination and spirit, completely unrelated to writing. This includes reading for pleasure (outside my genre), spending time in nature, or engaging in a non-writing hobby (e.g., painting, cooking, hiking). These are not optional, but essential.”
    • Example: “My personal ‘Creative Recharge’ rule: Every Saturday afternoon, I spend at least two hours in a local art museum or a botanical garden, simply observing and absorbing, without any pressure to create or analyze.”
  • Rule for Comparisonitis: How do you avoid the trap of comparing your journey to others?
    • Old Rule: Look to others for benchmarks of success.
    • New Rule: “My only metric for success is personal growth and the completion of my projects. When I find myself comparing my progress to another author’s, I will consciously shift my focus back to my own ‘Why’ and congratulate the other writer on their success, then refocus on my next immediate task.”
    • Concrete Action: Define your “Why.” Is it to tell a specific story? To connect with a particular audience? To explore a theme? Write your “Why” down and look at it every time you feel the sting of comparison.

The Art of Rule Implementation: From Theory to Practice

Writing down your rules is only the first step. The true power lies in their consistent application.

  1. Be Specific and Actionable: Vague rules are easily broken. Make them concrete. Instead of “I will write more,” make it “I will write 500 words before breakfast, five days a week.”
  2. Start Small, Iterate, and Adjust: You don’t need to overhaul your entire writing life overnight. Pick one or two areas that cause the most friction, define a rule, and implement it. Observe, analyze, and adjust as needed. Perhaps your initial rule of 500 words before breakfast is too ambitious. Adjust it to 250 words, or shift the time. These are your rules, not commandments etched in stone.
  3. Frame Rules Positively: Instead of “I won’t procrastinate,” try “I will start every writing session with a 15-minute focused sprint.”
  4. Understand Your Personal “Why”: Each rule should align with your overarching purpose as a writer. If a rule feels arbitrary or restrictive without a clear benefit, re-evaluate it. Your “Why” might be to explore complex human emotions, to build immersive worlds, or to simply enjoy the act of storytelling. Each rule should serve that core purpose.
  5. Visualize Success: Imagine yourself successfully adhering to your rules. How does it feel? This mental rehearsal can reinforce positive habits.
  6. Create Triggers and Reminders: Just as your rule for idea generation might involve carrying a notebook, your rule for writing time might involve a specific alarm or a dedicated, uncluttered space. These triggers cue the desired behavior.
  7. Forgive Lapses, Don’t Abandon: You will break your rules. It’s inevitable. The key is not to let a single lapse derail your entire system. Acknowledge it, learn from it, and gently guide yourself back. Your rules are a framework, not a cage.
  8. Regular Review and Revision: Your writing life evolves, your goals shift, and your understanding of yourself deepens. Set a periodic review (monthly, quarterly) to assess your rules. Are they still serving you? Do any need to be retired, updated, or added? Your definitions of success, your preferred genres, or even your peak writing times might change over time. Your rules must adapt.

Embracing Your Authority: The Writer as Architect of Self

Writing your own rules is an act of profound self-authorship. It’s about taking responsibility for your creative journey, defining success on your own terms, and building a sustainable, fulfilling writing life. It liberates you from the tyranny of external expectations and the endless pursuit of someone else’s definition of “good.”

When you meticulously craft and consistently apply your own rules, you cease to be a passive participant in the often-chaotic world of writing. You become the conscious architect, the deliberate craftsman, the visionary leader of your own literary destiny. This isn’t just about productivity; it’s about peace of mind, sustained creative passion, and the unwavering conviction that your unique voice deserves to be heard, on your own terms. Begin today. Define your rules, live by them, and watch your writing flourish.