Every compelling film, every binge-worthy series, every enthralling play that’s ever captivated me, it all starts not with a massive script, but with something tiny, yet powerful. It’s the concept. That single, electrifying idea that underpins everything. It’s the very DNA of your story, dictating its potential, its reach, and how much it’ll resonate with people. Believe me, without a strong concept, even the most beautifully written prose or the most intricate plot will just feel hollow, like it’s drifting in a sea of “almosts.” So, this guide? Think of it as my blueprint for how I go about building that foundational strength, moving past fleeting inspirations to create a concept that simply demands to be told.
Beyond the “What If?”: What I Mean by a Truly Strong Concept
You know, a lot of writers, myself included sometimes, can confuse just a premise with a true concept. A premise might be something simple, like, “What if a wizard went to high school?” But a concept? That’s when I dig deeper. I marry that “what if” with inherent conflict, rich characters, and thematic potential. For me, it’s the logline even before the logline, that core idea that sells itself.
When I think about what makes a concept strong, I’m looking for a few key attributes:
- Clarity: It’s got to be instantly understandable, even to someone who knows nothing about the genre I’m working in.
- Intrigue: It has to spark curiosity. I want people to immediately lean in and say, “Tell me more!”
- Inherent Conflict: It needs to contain the seeds of dramatic tension right there at its core.
- Relatability/Universality: While it can be super specific, it also needs to tap into broader human experiences or emotions.
- Commercial Appeal (It’s a Bonus, But Nice): For me, this means it hints at a target audience and whether it has market viability.
- Originality (with a Twist): I’m looking for a fresh spin on something familiar, or genuinely something I haven’t seen before.
I always think of it as a narrative promise. I’m promising the audience a unique experience, a fundamental question that’s going to be explored, or a character journey that’s going to resonate deeply.
Phase 1: The Spark – How I Identify and Capture Raw Ideas
Concepts don’t just appear out of nowhere for me. They often spring from moments of observation, personal experiences, current events, or even an unexpected collision of totally different ideas. This first phase is all about cultivating my creative fertile ground.
1. My Observation Journal: My Personal Idea Repository
I always carry a small notebook, or use a dedicated app on my phone. This isn’t just for those “aha!” moments of brilliance; it’s for capturing every tiny fragment.
- Overheard Dialogue: A quirky phrase, a tense exchange. For example: I once jotted down, “He said it was just a coincidence, but her eyes told a different story,” and that stuck with me.
- Peculiar News Stories: Unexplained phenomena, human interest pieces with an edge. Like that news story I read about a town where everyone inexplicably started speaking in rhymes.
- Personal Annoyances/Frustrations: These are often goldmines because they highlight universal struggles. For instance, the sheer impossibility of getting customer service to understand a complex technical issue – that could be a whole story in itself.
- Dream Fragments: Even though they’re often nonsensical, sometimes a striking image or feeling from a dream can be a great springboard. I once had a recurring dream of a city completely submerged in ice, and that’s been cooking in the back of my mind.
- “What If” Seeds: These are my initial, unfiltered questions. What if people could trade memories? That’s a classic one that always gets me thinking.
The key for me here is not to judge, just to capture. Volume totally matters at this stage.
2. Deconstructing Media: Beyond Enjoyment, Towards Understanding
I make a point to watch films, read books, play games, and consume news with a critical, analytical eye, not just for enjoyment.
- Identifying Core Concepts: What’s the single most powerful idea driving a story that I admire? Like with “Jaws,” it’s not just “shark attacks.” It’s “A massive killer shark terrorizes a small island community, forcing a reluctant police chief to confront it.” See how that adds layers of community, fear, and a specific protagonist’s challenge?
- Pinpointing My Dislikes/Gaps: What stories do I wish existed? What common tropes really annoy me? What feels unexplored? I often think, “I’m tired of space operas where the hero is always a white male. What if the hero was an aged, cynical, indigenous grandmother instead?”
- Analyzing Genre Conventions: What are the expectations? How can I subvert them? In horror, the monster is usually external. What if the monster is an internal, hereditary condition? I find those ideas fascinating.
This active engagement really helps me understand what works, what doesn’t, and where opportunities for novelty might be hiding.
3. The “Collision” Technique: Forced Juxtaposition
This is one of my favorite tricks: I take two completely unrelated concepts and force them together. This often generates the most startling and original ideas for me.
- Concept A + Concept B:
- Example 1: Zombie Apocalypse + Historical Romance = A regency-era gentlewoman must fight the reanimated dead while navigating societal expectations and an unwelcome suitor. (You’re totally thinking “Pride and Prejudice and Zombies” now, aren’t you?)
- Example 2: Time Travel + Stand-Up Comedy = A struggling comedian discovers he can time travel, but only to open mic nights in the past, leading to hilarious and disastrous attempts to steal famous jokes.
- Example 3: Artificial Intelligence + Wilderness Survival = An advanced AI, designed for urban utility, is accidentally stranded in a harsh wilderness, forced to adapt to primal survival without its usual resources.
The absurd initial combination actually forces my brain to bridge the gap, creating totally unexpected narrative pathways.
Phase 2: From Idea to Concept – How I Weed, Refine, and Interrogate
Once I’ve got a good collection of raw ideas, it’s time for me to put them under the microscope. This phase is all about figuring out which ideas have legs and how to really make them stronger.
1. The “So What?” Test: Unearthing Thematic Resonance
For every potential idea, I always ask myself: “So what?” What’s the deeper meaning or implication? Why should anyone actually care? This really pushes me beyond just plot mechanics.
- Raw Idea: A man invents a machine that can read minds.
- My “So What?” Questions:
- What are the ethical implications of mind-reading?
- How does it truly affect human connection, trust, and intimacy?
- Does it expose the truth, or just more layers of deception?
- Does it make people more empathetic or more isolated?
- What’s the universal human fear or desire being tapped into here?
- Concept I Developed: A brilliant but reclusive inventor creates a device that exposes the unfiltered thoughts of others, forcing him to confront the dark truths hidden beneath polite society and question whether true connection is possible without illusion. (See how it now has themes of truth vs. illusion, vulnerability, isolation, societal hypocrisy?)
This test is what transforms a cool gimmick into a potent thematic vehicle.
2. The Conflict Catalyst: Identifying the Core Struggle
A strong concept, for me, inherently contains conflict. It’s the engine of the story. So, I always identify the central opposing forces.
- Internal vs. External: Is the conflict mainly within the protagonist (like self-doubt, a moral dilemma) or external (like a villain, a natural disaster, societal pressure)? Often, it’s both.
- Man vs. Man: A direct antagonist.
- Man vs. Nature: Survival against the elements.
- Man vs. Society: Challenging norms, systems, or institutions.
- Man vs. Self: Overcoming personal flaws or internal struggles.
- Man vs. Technology/Supernatural/Fate: Broader, often abstract, forces.
-
Raw Idea: A group of survivors on a deserted island.
- Adding Conflict Layers (This is what I do):
- Man vs. Nature: What if they run out of water?
- Man vs. Man: What if a power struggle erupts among them?
- Man vs. Society (implied): Their previous societal rules crumble.
- Concept with Conflict: When a commercial airliner crashes on a seemingly deserted island, the diverse group of survivors, driven by primal fear and conflicting leadership styles, must battle not only the harsh elements but also their own dwindling humanity as rescue proves elusive.
Strong concepts, to me, always show, rather than tell, the seeds of major conflict.
3. The Character Connection: Who is the Story About?
While my concept isn’t a full character biography, it always has to suggest a compelling protagonist whose journey is essential to the idea.
- Who is uniquely positioned to face this concept’s challenges?
- Who has the most to lose or gain?
- Who represents the core theme?
-
Raw Idea: A pandemic turns people into sleepwalking zombies.
- Adding Character Connection (My thought process): Who would this be most devastating for?
- A doctor specializing in sleep disorders?
- A single parent struggling to keep their child awake?
- Someone with chronic insomnia, who is ironically immune?
- Concept with Character: As a mysterious global pandemic forces victims into a perpetual, violent sleepwalking state, an insomniac scientist, immune due to her unique brain chemistry, races against time to find a cure while battling her own crippling exhaustion and the terrifying reality that the only conscious beings left are her and the afflicted. (See how the character’s specific condition makes her totally pivotal to the concept?)
The character, for me, shouldn’t just exist within the concept; they should embody it or be uniquely affected by it.
4. The Originality Pulse: The “Twist”
True originality is actually pretty rare. What’s more common, and often far more effective for me, is a fresh spin on a familiar premise. This is where my “twist” comes in.
- Familiar Trope: Heist movie.
- The Twist (My brainstorming):
- Example 1 (Character Twist): What if the heist team is composed entirely of retirees from a nursing home?
- Example 2 (Setting Twist): What if the heist takes place during a live, televised chess tournament?
- Example 3 (Goal Twist): What if they aren’t stealing money; they’re stealing the world’s last unread book?
- Concept with Twist: A group of disgruntled, technologically-savvy elderly residents from a luxury retirement home conspire to execute history’s most intricate art heist – not for profit, but to fund their community’s failing pension plan before the bank seizes their beloved home.
The twist elevates a generic idea into something distinctive and memorable. It should always feel organic, never just tacked on.
5. The Elevator Pitch: Condensing to Its Essence
I always boil my concept down to a single, compelling sentence or two. If I can’t, then it’s not clear enough. This is my “logline for the concept.”
- My Formula: When [inciting incident], a [protagonist type] must [protagonist’s goal] before [stakes/consequences] or risk [catastrophe].
- Example (from my earlier development): When a commercial airliner crashes on a seemingly deserted island, the diverse group of survivors, driven by primal fear and conflicting leadership styles, must battle not only the harsh elements but also their own dwindling humanity as rescue proves elusive.
This forces clarity and highlights all those core elements I just developed: conflict, character, and stakes. I always practice saying it aloud. Does it grab attention? Does it make someone want to know more?
Phase 3: Stress-Testing and Solidifying My Concept
A concept isn’t truly strong until it can actually withstand scrutiny. This phase is all about rigorous evaluation for me.
1. The “What If This Happened Instead?” Exercise: Testing Plot Durability
I like to imagine alternative outcomes or paths for my concept. Does it still hold up? This helps me ensure my concept is robust, not brittle.
- Concept: A detective is brought in to solve a seemingly impossible murder where the victim was alone in a locked room.
- Variations/Stress Tests (How I push it):
- What if the victim wasn’t actually alone? (That adds a whole new layer of deception)
- What if the “locked room” wasn’t what it seemed (maybe an illusion)? (Now we’re talking supernatural or technological twist)
- What if the detective is the only one who believes it’s murder, and everyone else thinks it was suicide? (That totally adds a man vs. society conflict)
- What if the detective accidentally caused the “impossible” murder in a previous case and is now solving his own mistake? (That brings in man vs. self and a moral dilemma)
- Purpose: This exercise really reveals the core strength of my initial idea. If it collapses with minor changes, it might be too thin. But if it allows for fascinating new avenues, then I know it’s robust.
2. The Genre Alignment Check: Setting Expectations
While innovation is absolutely vital, understanding where my concept fits (even if it’s imperfectly) helps me focus its development and marketing.
- Does it clearly lean towards a specific genre? (Thriller, Sci-Fi, Romance, Comedy, Horror, Drama)
- Does it fuse genres? (Sci-Fi Western, Horror Comedy)
- What are the expectations of that genre? How will I meet or subvert them?
- Example: A concept for a horror film needs to deliver dread, tension, and a sense of threat. A comedy needs to deliver laughs. A romance needs compelling relational obstacles and eventual payoff.
- Self-Correction: If my concept feels like it’s trying to be five things at once, it probably lacks focus. I choose a primary genre identity and build from there.
3. The “Broad Appeal vs. Niche” Assessment: Market Considerations
While not every concept needs to be a blockbuster, understanding its potential audience is key for me.
- Is this a concept with universal appeal? (like love, loss, good vs. evil, survival)
- Is it highly specific or niche? (like a story about competitive synchronized swimming in the 1950s)
- Are there existing successful examples of similar concepts? This isn’t about replication, but about market viability.
- Who would be excited to see this? What age group? What demographic?
- Example: A concept about an alien invasion is broad appeal. A concept about a philosophical debate between two AI in a simulated medieval kingdom is more niche. Both can be successful, but their development and marketing will differ.
This assessment really helps me gauge the ambition and scope of my project.
4. The Passion Test: Do I Actually Want to Spend Years with This Idea?
This is perhaps the most critical test for me. Developing a script is a marathon. My concept must sustain my interest, inspire me, and challenge me.
- Does the concept genuinely excite me, even after scrutinizing it?
- Do I feel a deep curiosity about its implications?
- Am I driven to explore its characters and conflicts?
- Does it resonate with my personal beliefs or experiences?
If my enthusiasm wanes, even after the rigorous development process, that’s a red flag for me. I move on. There are countless ideas out there. I only invest my energy in the one that truly captivates me.
Conclusion: The Concept as a Living Seed
My concept isn’t a static declaration; it’s a living seed. It will grow, adapt, and deepen as I flesh out my characters, plot, and themes. But a strong concept provides that unshakeable taproot, anchoring my entire narrative. It’s what I sell, what I build upon, and what ultimately resonates with my audience. I always make sure to invest the time in this foundational stage, because the rest of my script will rise on a bedrock of power and potential. The clearer, more intriguing, and more fundamentally strong my concept, the more compelling my entire story will become. I always begin here, with unwavering focus, and that ensures my script has the very best start.