How to Get Your Play Produced by a Community Theater: Start Locally.

by

I’m going to share with you something that many of us who write plays dream about: seeing our words come to life on stage. Now, Broadway and even big regional theaters can feel like these massive, distant goals, right? But listen, there’s this incredible, vibrant world out there that’s totally within reach: community theater. It’s often where the pure love for performance shines brightest, and where new voices like ours can really get a foothold.

Getting your play produced by a local community theater isn’t about already knowing all the right people or having a resume a mile long. It’s truly about understanding how these unique groups operate, writing a submission that grabs their attention, and building genuine connections. I’m going to walk you through everything you need to know and the steps you can take to make that dream a reality, specifically focusing on how your local community can be your perfect launching pad.

The Quiet Strength of Local Stages: Why Community Theater Matters

Before we dive into the “how-to,” let’s just take a moment to understand why community theater is so incredibly important. These theaters are the heart of our local arts scenes. They run on passion, often on shoestring budgets, and are powered by amazing volunteers who genuinely love what they do. This environment, far from being a limitation, is actually your biggest advantage.

  • It’s Accessible: Unlike professional theaters that usually have strict processes for new plays, community theaters are often much more open to submissions, especially from writers right in their own community.
  • They’re Willing to Try New Things: While they definitely appreciate plays that appeal to everyone, many community theaters are really eager to put on fresh, original works that speak to their specific audience or challenge their cast in exciting ways.
  • It Builds Your Resume: Let’s be clear: a community theater production is a legitimate production. It shows you can write for the stage, gives you solid proof of your work, and provides invaluable hands-on experience.
  • You Get Direct Feedback: Chances are, you’ll be much more involved in the process, which means you’ll get to interact directly with the actors, directors, and even the audience. You’ll gain insights you just can’t get from sitting alone with your script.
  • Networking on a Human Scale: The relationships you build here are often deep and real, and they can absolutely lead to future opportunities within your local arts world.

Think of it this way: you’re planting a seed in really fertile ground. The growth might not be as explosive as a big commercial production, but the roots you establish will be strong, and the entire experience will be deeply enriching.

Understanding Your Local Scene: Researching Target Theaters

You wouldn’t send a heavy winter coat to someone living on a tropical island, right? Similarly, you shouldn’t send a sprawling historical epic to a small black box theater that only does contemporary comedies. Good research is the absolute foundation of a successful submission.

  • Find Local Theaters: Start with a simple Google search. Try “[Your City/Region] Community Theater,” or “Amateur Theater [Your State],” or even “Local Playhouses [Your Zip Code].” Check out community calendars, local arts council websites, and don’t forget your public library’s arts section. And hey, sometimes college or university theater departments might work with community groups or have student productions that are open to outside submissions. It’s worth a look!
  • Dig Into Their Past Shows: Once you’ve got a list, really dig into what they’ve produced before. Most theaters have a “past productions” section on their websites. What kind of plays do they usually do?
    • Genres: Are they big on musicals? Do they lean towards comedies, dramas, or mysteries? Do they prefer classics or more modern works?
    • Scale: Do they put on huge shows with massive casts, or do they stick to intimate one-act plays? Look at how many actors are usually in their programs.
    • Themes: Are they generally family-friendly, or do they tackle more challenging, adult themes?
    • Set Needs: Look at photos from their past productions. Do they tend to use really intricate sets or more minimalist designs? This gives you clues about their technical capabilities and how much money they have for sets.
  • Read Their Mission Statement (If You Find One): Many community theaters have a mission statement that spells out their artistic goals, their commitment to the community, and their values. Do you see your play fitting in with what they’re trying to achieve? For example, if a theater’s mission is “to bring diverse and inclusive stories to our community,” a play with a wide range of characters and experiences might be a perfect fit.
  • Go See a Show: This is a must-do. There’s just no substitute for seeing a theater’s work firsthand.
    • Watch the Audience: Who’s coming to their shows? What are their demographics? This tells you a lot about the community’s tastes.
    • Check the Production Quality: How strong is the acting? The directing? The technical stuff? This helps you figure out their capabilities and if the complexity of your play matches what they typically produce.
    • Get a Feel for the Vibe: Does it feel welcoming? Does it feel professional, even if it’s amateur?
  • Look for Submission Guidelines: After you’ve seen a show, specifically check their website for sections like “New Play Submissions,” “Unsolicited Scripts,” or similar headings. Some theaters have a formal process, while others might not even accept unsolicited material. Don’t get discouraged if a few don’t; just move on to the next one!

Here’s a concrete example: Let’s say you live in “Maple Creek, PA.” You do your research and find “Maple Creek Community Players.” Their website lists past productions like Our Town, Arsenic and Old Lace, You Can’t Take It With You, and a recent run of Boeing Boeing. This immediately tells you they favor classic, ensemble-driven comedies and dramas, and probably plays that don’t need super elaborate sets. The fact they did Boeing Boeing suggests they can handle farce and quick pacing. If your play is a two-character avant-garde drama that’s entirely set in darkness, Maple Creek Players might not be your first choice. But if it’s a family-friendly comedy with 8-10 characters and settings that can be easily adapted, you’re definitely in the right ballpark!

Shaping Your Play: Writing for Community Theater’s Realities

Once you’ve identified some potential theaters, it’s time to really look at your play through the lens of community theater practicalities. This isn’t about compromising your artistic vision, but rather understanding where it can truly thrive.

  • Cast Size: This is incredibly important. Plays with really large casts (15+) are tough for most community theaters because of space, scheduling everyone, and just finding enough committed actors. So, a smaller to medium cast (4-12) is generally much more appealing.
    • Doubling Potential: Can some actors play multiple, distinct roles without confusing the audience? This is a really common and welcome technique.
    • Age Range: Community theaters usually have a wide range of actors available. Plays that offer roles for teenagers, young adults, middle-aged people, and seniors are highly attractive. A play that needs five male leads all in their 20s might be much harder to cast than one with a more diverse mix of ages and genders.
  • Staging & Technical Demands:
    • Sets: Multiple, super elaborate set changes are often just not possible. Plays with a single, flexible set, or minimal changes between scenes, are significantly more appealing. Think about how easily your scenes can flow with just simple furniture rearrangement or lighting shifts.
    • Props: While unique props can add charm, plays that require dozens of specific, hard-to-find, or expensive props can be a real deterrent.
    • Lighting/Sound: Does your play require complex lighting cues (like strobe effects, or specific color washes for every single line) or intricate sound design (say, 20 unique sound effects in one scene)? Simpler demands are definitely preferred.
  • Content & Theme:
    • Audience Appeal: While some community theaters are daring, many cater to a broad local audience that includes families. Explicit language, excessive violence, or really controversial themes might limit your play’s chances. Consider if your themes are universally relatable or if they appeal to a specific local demographic.
    • Runtime: One-act plays (30-60 minutes) are often great for festivals, as a short piece before a main production, or as part of an evening of short plays. Full-length plays typically run 90-120 minutes without an intermission, or about 2 hours with one. Plays that are extremely long (3 hours+) are quite rare for community groups.
  • Local Connection (Optional but Powerful): Does your play somehow connect with local history, local issues, or local values? A story about a specific local phenomenon, a historical event from your town, or a theme that really speaks to the demographic of your area can create a truly strong emotional connection with a community theater and its audience.

Here’s another concrete example: Let’s say you’ve written this amazing play called “The Last Bloom,” which is about a florist whose shop is facing a corporate takeover. It has 15 characters, including five distinct members of a rock band, it needs a fully functional flower shop set, and it ends with a complex pyrotechnic display. You quickly realize this is a long shot for Maple Creek Players. So, you decide to revise:
* Characters: You reduce the band to 3 members, with two characters also doubling as flower shop employees (bringing the cast size down to 11).
* Set: You redesign the flower shop to be a single, adaptable space, using rolling carts and modular shelves instead of fixed counters.
* Ending: You replace the pyrotechnics with a powerful lighting and sound sequence that effectively symbolizes a dramatic moment.
This thoughtful revision makes your play much, much more attractive to a community theater without sacrificing its core story!

Creating the Irresistible Submission Package

Even for theaters that don’t have super formal guidelines, a polished, professional submission really makes a lasting impression. Your goal here is clarity, conciseness, and completeness.

  • The Query Letter/Email (Your Cover Letter): This is your first impression, so keep it professional, to the point, and persuasive.
    • To Whom It May Concern: Address it to a specific person if you can (like the Artistic Director, Literary Manager, or Play Reading Committee Chair). If you can’t find a name, “Dear [Theater Name] Production Team” or “Dear Artistic Director” works just fine.
    • Introduction: Briefly introduce yourself and your play’s title.
    • Logline: This is a super compelling one-sentence summary of your play. (For example: “In the sleepy town of Willow Creek, a forgotten diary unearths a century-old secret, forcing a reclusive librarian to confront her own family’s past.”)
    • Synopsis: A concise paragraph (50-100 words) summarizing the plot, main characters, and the central conflict. Focus on intriguing hooks, not every single plot twist.
    • Why Them? This part is crucial for local theaters. Explain why you truly believe your play is a good fit for their theater. Refer to their past productions, their mission, or how it connects to the community. (For example: “Given your impressive past productions of character-driven comedies like ‘You Can’t Take It With You,’ I believe the ensemble nature and humorous family dynamics of ‘The Last Bloom’ would resonate strongly with your audience.”)
    • Practicalities: Briefly mention the cast size (including any doubling potential) and the main set requirements.
    • Availability: State that you’re willing to answer questions, participate in readings, or be involved in the production process (if you are).
    • Call to Action: State what you’ve included (your script, character breakdown, etc.) and politely ask for their consideration.
    • Professional Closing: “Sincerely,” “Respectfully,” followed by your name and contact information (phone, email, website/online portfolio if you have one).
  • The Script (Professionally Formatted):
    • Title Page: This should include your play title, your name, and your contact information.
    • Character Breakdown: A concise list of all characters, their approximate age range, and a brief description. Make it clear if any roles can be doubled. (For example: “MARTHA (40s-50s) – Gruff but kind flower shop owner.”)
    • Setting: A brief description of where the play takes place.
    • Page Numbering: This is essential for easy reading!
    • Standard Play Format: Use a widely accepted format (like indents for character names, centered character names, stage directions in italics or parentheses, clear blocking cues). Consistency is key here.
    • Proofread Meticulously: Typos, grammatical errors, and formatting inconsistencies are major red flags. Read it aloud, and have other people read it too.
    • PDF is Your Best Friend: Unless they specify otherwise, always send your script as a PDF to ensure the formatting stays exactly as you intended.
  • Synopsis/Short Treatment: This would be a more detailed, one-page summary that goes deeper into the plot, character arcs, and themes. This is separate from the brief synopsis in your cover letter.
  • Playwright Bio: A concise paragraph (50-75 words) about your writing background, relevant experience, and any previous productions (even readings or college productions count!). Focus on what makes you a good candidate.
  • Optional Enhancements (Use Sparingly):
    • 10-Page Sample: If a full script submission isn’t accepted right away, you can offer to send a compelling 10-page sample to pique their interest.
    • Marketing Hooks: If your play has a really strong hook (like, “Perfect for theaters looking for a holiday production,” or “Features roles for three strong women”), you can subtly include this in your cover letter.

Concrete Example: Your submission for “The Last Bloom” to Maple Creek Players would definitely include:
* A concise cover letter that clearly explains why your play, with its ensemble humor and relatable themes, perfectly aligns with their proven history of successful comedies like You Can’t Take It With You.
* A professionally formatted PDF script of “The Last Bloom,” with a clear character breakdown (and specifically identifying doubling potential).
* A brief playwright bio that highlights your relevant writing experience.
* And every single part of this package would be meticulously proofread.

The Waiting Game and Following Up Politely

Once you’ve sent your submission, patience is absolutely key. Remember, community theaters are often run by dedicated volunteers who have full-time jobs. Their submission review processes can be slow.

  • Patience is a Virtue: Expect to wait weeks, possibly even months, for a response. Sending follow-up emails every few days won’t speed things up and can actually be quite annoying.
  • Follow Up Appropriately: If you haven’t heard anything after 8-12 weeks, a polite, brief email is perfectly acceptable. Something like: “Dear [Recipient], I hope this email finds you well. I submitted my play, ‘The Last Bloom,’ on [Date] and am writing to politely inquire about the status of my submission. Please let me know if you require any further information from my end. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, [Your Name].”
  • No Response Isn’t Always a “No”: Sometimes, theaters simply don’t have the capacity to respond to every single submission, especially if they’ve received a huge number. Try not to take it personally.
  • Keep Writing: While you’re waiting, please don’t stop creating! Start your next play, revise an old one, get involved in other writing activities. Productive waiting is truly the best kind.

Building Relationships: Beyond the Submission

A successful submission is a huge step, but cultivating ongoing relationships within your local theater community can lead to truly profound and lasting benefits.

  • Volunteer: Offer your time and your skills. Help with building sets, ushering, working on costumes, or managing props. This gets your face known, shows how committed you are, and lets you see how the theater operates from the inside. You’ll meet the artistic director, board members, and other key people in a relaxed, collaborative environment.
  • Attend Events: Go to their fundraisers, season announcements, and other community gatherings. Show genuine interest in what they do.
  • Be a Good Audience Member: Go see their shows. Buy tickets. Spread positive word-of-mouth about them.
  • Offer to Read: If they hold play readings (whether it’s a staged reading or just a table read), offer your services as a reader. This is a fantastic way to meet directors and actors and show that you understand theatrical work.
  • Local Playwright Groups: Is there a group of local playwrights or a writing group? Join it! Critiquing each other’s work and sharing resources can be incredibly valuable. If one doesn’t exist, maybe think about starting one yourself?
  • Always Be Professional: Whether your play is accepted or rejected, always maintain a respectful and gracious demeanor. The theater world is much smaller than you think, especially at the local level, and reputations really do precede people. A “no” today could very well turn into a “yes” two seasons from now if you’ve shown you’re easy to work with.
  • Learn from Feedback: If you get specific feedback on your play, consider it carefully. It doesn’t mean you have to use every single suggestion, but understanding how your work is perceived is crucial for your growth as a writer.

Concrete Example: Maple Creek Players rejects “The Last Bloom” for their upcoming season, saying they’re already committed to a classic Shakespearean play. Instead of feeling defeated, you offer to help usher for Hamlet. During intermission, you chat with the Artistic Director, who remembers your submission and is impressed by your willingness to help out. You learn they’re thinking about a new play festival next year and that they were particularly drawn to your play’s strong female characters. This informal conversation gives you invaluable insight and potentially a direct path for a future submission.

The Next Steps: If Your Play is Accepted

Congratulations! This is the moment you’ve worked so hard for. Approaching this phase with an open mind and a collaborative spirit is absolutely vital.

  • Understand Expectations: Be clear on the terms of the production. Will you be involved in casting? Rehearsals? Design? What do they expect from you in terms of availability?
  • Collaborate, Don’t Control: Remember, a production is a collaborative art form. The director, actors, and designers will bring their own interpretations to your script. Be open to their ideas, listen to their challenges, and be willing to make smart revisions for the stage. Think of your script as the blueprint, but the production is the actual house.
  • Be Present (But Not Clingy): Attend rehearsals when you’re invited. Be available for questions. Offer insights when it’s appropriate, but avoid micromanaging or correcting actors directly. Trust the director.
  • Learn from the Process: Watch how your words translate to the stage. Pay attention to where lines land well, where the pacing drags, or where a moment isn’t clear to the audience. This live feedback is an incredible masterclass in playwriting.
  • Embrace the Journey: There will be ups and downs. Challenges and triumphs. Embrace the entire experience, from the first read-through to opening night.

The Priceless Lessons from a Local Production

Even if your show only runs for a few nights in a small community hall, the lessons you’ll learn are absolutely immense.

  • The Power of Collaboration: You’ll truly understand how crucial a strong director, dedicated actors, and resourceful designers are to bringing a script to life.
  • Audience Connection: You’ll witness real-time reactions – the laughter, the gasps, the tears. This direct feedback is irreplaceable for understanding how your work lands with an audience.
  • Practicality of the Stage: You’ll gain a much deeper appreciation for set changes, lighting cues, sound design, costuming, and the sheer logistical effort required for a production. This will inform your future writing, making you a more “stage-aware” playwright.
  • Resilience: The process can be challenging. You’ll face rewrites, differing opinions, and unforeseen obstacles. Navigating these builds resilience and problem-solving skills you’ll use in all areas of your life.
  • The Value of Your Voice: Seeing your words performed, hearing laughter or emotional silences from an audience, truly solidifies the impact that your unique voice has. It will fuel your desire to write even more.

Getting your play produced by a community theater isn’t a shortcut; it’s a legitimate, incredibly enriching pathway for playwrights. It’s about being strategic, understanding the local ecosystem, and being willing to engage authentically. Start locally, build those strong roots, and watch your theatrical dreams truly begin to blossom.