How to Avoid Common Agent Pitfalls

by

The allure of a literary agent is undeniable. For many writers, it’s the golden key to unlocking publishing dreams, the gatekeeper to the hallowed halls of traditional presses. Yet, this vital relationship, while often symbiotic and highly beneficial, is fraught with potential pitfalls. Missteps, misunderstandings, or even outright bad actors can derail careers, waste precious time, and inflict significant emotional and financial stress. This comprehensive guide dissects the most common agent-related pitfalls, offering actionable strategies to navigate the complex literary landscape with confidence, safeguarding your precious work and your professional journey.

The Quest for Representation: Beyond the Hype

Before delving into the specific pitfalls, it’s crucial to establish a foundational understanding: finding an agent is an active, research-intensive process, not a passive one. Many writers, fueled by anthology success stories, believe agents are simply waiting to discover their genius. This romantic notion leads directly to the first set of vulnerabilities.

Pitfall 1: Unrealistic Expectations and Naivety

The Problem: Many writers enter the agent search believing all agents are equally skilled, ethical, and actively seeking their specific manuscript. They may assume an agent will perform miracles, instantly transforming a manuscript into a bestseller without significant revision or collaboration. This naivety can lead to signing with the wrong person, or worse, falling prey to predatory practices.

Actionable Solution: Embrace Due Diligence as Your Primary Shield.

  • Deep Dive Research: Never query an agent without researching their sales history, client list, recent deals, and online presence. Use publisher’s marketplace, their agency website, and social media (with caution, verifying claims). Look for authors in your genre. What books have they sold recently? Are those books similar in tone or theme to yours, or is there a clear diversification?
    • Example: An agent claims to represent “bestselling thrillers.” Your research on Publisher’s Marketplace shows they’ve sold two thrillers in the last three years, both from established authors, and their primary sales are in young adult fantasy. This isn’t necessarily a red flag, but it is an indicator that thrillers aren’t their primary focus, despite the claim. Your expectation for their expertise should adjust accordingly.
  • Understand Agent-Editor Relationship: Agents don’t make a book a bestseller. They facilitate connections. They pitch to editors they have relationships with. A strong agent likely has deep, established relationships in your specific genre. Understand that even the best agent can’t force an editor to acquire a book they don’t love.
  • Financial Reality: Agents only make money when you make money. Their standard commission is 15% domestic, 20% foreign. Anyone asking for an upfront fee for reading, editing, or “marketing” your manuscript is a scammer. Period. This is non-negotiable.
    • Example: An agent offers you representation but then says, “Before I can shop this, it needs a professional line edit. My preferred editor charges $2,500, which you’d pay directly.” This is a classic scam. Reputable agents might suggest edits, but they will never charge you for them, nor will they mandate you use a specific paid service as a condition of representation.

Pitfall 2: The “Any Agent is Better Than No Agent” Fallacy

The Problem: Desperation often leads writers to accept representation from the first agent who offers, regardless of fit, experience, or reputation. This fear of being unrepresented can lock you into a detrimental relationship, holding your manuscript hostage or mismanaging your career.

Actionable Solution: Prioritize the Right Fit Over Immediate Gratification.

  • Interview Your Agent: An offer of representation is not a marriage proposal. It’s a job offer (for them, to work for you). Ask probing questions.
    • Example Questions:
      • “What do you envision as the next steps for this manuscript? What kind of editors or houses do you see it being a fit for?” (Listen for specific names, not just genres).
      • “What constructive feedback do you have on the manuscript, and how do you see us working together on revisions?” (Their feedback should align with your vision and demonstrate a deep understanding of your work).
      • “How do you handle foreign rights, film/TV rights, and subsidiary rights?”
      • “What is your communication style? How often can I expect updates?”
      • “What is your standard agency agreement? Can I review it with legal counsel?”
      • “How many authors do you represent, and how many new clients do you take on annually?” (An overly large client list might mean less individual attention).
  • Trust Your Gut (and Get a Second Opinion): If something feels off, it probably is. If an agent seems overly enthusiastic without specific feedback, or promises unrealistic outcomes, exercise extreme caution. Discuss the offer with trusted writer friends or a critique partner.
  • Vet Background and History: Search for the agent’s name followed by “scam,” “bad reviews,” or “complaints.” While the internet is not always reliable, consistent patterns of negative feedback are serious warning signs. Check writer forums and professional organizations for discussions about specific agents.
    • Example: You receive an offer from “Agent X.” A quick search reveals multiple forum posts detailing how Agent X frequently offers representation but then fails to submit manuscripts, or sits on them for years without explanation. This is a massive red flag that overrides any perceived benefit of having an agent.

The Agent-Client Relationship: Navigating the Partnership

Once an offer of representation is on the table, and you’ve accepted, the work of managing the relationship truly begins. This is where many writers, excited by the “win,” drop their guard.

Pitfall 3: Poor Communication and Lack of Clarity

The Problem: Communication breakdown is a leading cause of agent-client friction. This can manifest as an agent being unresponsive, vague, or not keeping the writer informed about submissions, rejections, or overall strategy. Conversely, writers can be overly demanding, unclear in their expectations, or fail to understand the agent’s responsibilities.

Actionable Solution: Establish and Maintain Clear Communication Protocols.

  • Define Communication Expectations Early: During the offer call, ask about their preferred communication method (email, phone), frequency of updates, and response times. Set realistic expectations for both sides.
    • Example: “I understand you’re busy, but I’d appreciate a quick email update monthly on submissions, even if there’s no new news. What’s your typical response time for non-urgent emails?”
  • Calendar Check-ins: If your contract allows, and it feels appropriate, suggest quarterly or semi-annual check-in calls to discuss your progress, their strategy, and future projects.
  • Be Specific and Concise: When you initiate communication, be clear and to the point.
    • Bad Example: “Hey, just checking in. Anything happening?” (Too vague, requires agent to sift through everything).
    • Good Example: “Hi [Agent Name], I’m finalizing revisions on Project B. Do you have any updates on Submissions for Project A to share?” (Clear, direct, actionable).
  • Understand the Submissions Process: Your agent is likely submitting to multiple editors simultaneously. Each submission can take weeks or months for a response. A lack of immediate news isn’t a sign of inactivity; it’s often a sign of waiting. Don’t bombard them with daily or weekly “any news?” emails.

Pitfall 4: Mismanagement of Expectations (Yours and Theirs)

The Problem: Writers often expect a book to sell quickly, for a large advance, and to be met with universal acclaim. Agents, on the other hand, might over-promise or fail to clearly articulate the realities of the market, leading to disappointment and fractured trust.

Actionable Solution: Foster Realistic Expectations and Proactive Problem-Solving.

  • Market Realities: The vast majority of books do not become bestsellers. Advances are often modest, especially for debut authors. Be aware of the average advance for your genre. Your agent should be honest about the market for your specific book.
    • Example: If your agent says, “This is a great book, I think it’s a six-figure advance,” but your book is in a very niche subgenre that historically fetches smaller advances, ask why they believe that. What data or comparable sales are they basing that on?
  • Understand the “No News is Good News” Misconception: In publishing, “no news” often just means no news. Editors are swamped. Rejection is standard. Your agent isn’t keeping information from you; they simply might not have any.
  • Set Goals Beyond the Book: Work with your agent to discuss not just the sale of this book, but your long-term career goals. Are you planning a series? Do you have other projects? A good agent thinks about your career arc, not just one book.
  • Address Concerns Promptly: If you have concerns about the submission process, lack of updates, or your book’s performance, address them calmly and directly. Don’t let resentment fester.
    • Example: Instead of, “Why haven’t you sold my book yet?!” try, “I’m feeling a bit anxious about the submission process. Could we schedule a call to discuss the editor feedback we’ve received so far and perhaps re-evaluate our strategy?”

Contractual Quagmires: Beyond the Handshake

An agent agreement is a legal document. Many writers, eager to sign, skim or entirely skip crucial clauses. This is a critical error.

Pitfall 5: Ignorance of the Agent-Client Agreement

The Problem: Many writers sign an agent agreement without fully understanding its terms, duration, termination clauses, or subsidiary rights representation. This can lead to being locked into a relationship you want to exit, losing control over certain rights, or being liable for unforeseen costs.

Actionable Solution: Scrutinize Every Clause, Seek Counsel if Needed.

  • Read Every Word: Read the contract thoroughly. Do not skim. Highlight anything you don’t understand.
  • Key Clauses to Understand:
    • Term (Duration): Is it for a specific project? Or for all your literary output? What’s the initial term (e.g., one year, two years)? Does it auto-renew?
    • Termination Clause: This is paramount. How can either party terminate the agreement? What is the notice period? Crucially, what happens to manuscripts already submitted or under contract upon termination? A common clause states the agent continues to receive commission on any deals made during the term, even if the money comes in after termination, or on books submitted by them that later sell, even if you terminate and get a new agent. This is generally standard, but understand its implications.
      • Example: A contract states, “Agent reserves the right to commission on any manuscript submitted during the term of this agreement that sells within two years of termination.” If you fire your agent and six months later your former agent’s submission sells, they are generally entitled to their commission. This means due diligence and a clear understanding of submitted materials are vital upon termination.
    • Scope of Representation: Does the agent represent all your literary works or just specific genres/projects? What about foreign rights, film/TV, audiobooks, merchandising? Are they handled in-house or by a sub-agent?
    • Agent’s Commission: Standard is 15% domestic, 20% foreign/subsidiary. Any higher without clear justification is suspect.
    • Expenses: What expenses, if any, can the agent pass on to you? (e.g., postage, special messenger fees for large contracts). Reputable agents typically absorb most minor expenses. Significant expenses (e.g., international travel for a book fair) should be discussed and agreed upon in writing beforehand.
    • Dispute Resolution: How are disagreements handled? Arbitration? Litigation?
  • Seek Legal Opinion: For significant career contracts, it’s always wise to have a lawyer specializing in literary contracts review the agreement. Small agencies may use standard, fair contracts. Larger agencies might have non-negotiable terms. A lawyer can clarify the implications of each clause. This is an investment in your career, not an unnecessary expense.

Pitfall 6: Relinquishing Control Over Subsidiary Rights

The Problem: Many writers don’t fully understand subsidiary rights (film, TV, audio, foreign, merchandising, etc.) or assume their agent is an expert in all of them. An agent without strong sub-rights contacts, or an agreement that doesn’t explicitly delineate how these are handled, can leave significant revenue streams untapped.

Actionable Solution: Delineate Subsidiary Rights Management Clearly.

  • Ask About Sub-Agents: Does the agency have a dedicated foreign rights department or an in-house film/TV agent, or do they work with external sub-agents? If external, who are they, and what are their commissions?
    • Example: “Do you handle foreign rights in-house, or do you have a specific foreign rights sub-agent you work with? What’s their typical commission, and how do they communicate with you and me?”
  • Understand Commission Structure: The standard 20% commission on subsidiary rights often includes the sub-agent’s cut. Ensure you know how this is divided if an outside party is involved.
  • Proactive Discussion on Non-Book Rights: If your book has strong film adaptation potential, discuss this with your agent upfront. Do they have connections in Hollywood? Are they actively pitching to studios? If not, do they recommend a separate film agent?
  • Right to Approve/Refuse: Ensure your contract states that no subsidiary rights deal can be closed without your final approval. This empowers you to refuse a bad deal.

Post-Sale Perils: Maintaining the Partnership

Selling a book is a monumental achievement, but it’s not the finish line. The agent’s role continues, and new pitfalls emerge in the post-publication landscape.

Pitfall 7: Neglecting Post-Sale Responsibilities

The Problem: Some agents, once a book deal is secured, become less engaged. They might neglect to chase overdue payments, fail to advocate for your next project, or become unresponsive to marketing/publicity questions.

Actionable Solution: Maintain Engagement and Proactively Manage Your Career.

  • Payment Tracking: Publishers are notorious for slow payments. Keep meticulous records of your contract’s payment schedule and advances. Your agent’s job includes ensuring you receive your money on time. Don’t be afraid to politely follow up.
    • Example: If a payment is due on July 1st and it’s mid-July, email your agent: “Just wanted to check if the [amount/payment name] for [Book Title] has come in yet? No rush, just keeping track.”
  • Advocacy for Next Projects: A good agent isn’t just a book-seller; they’re a career architect. Discuss your next book ideas long before the current one is out. They should be helping you strategize your next steps.
  • Understand Agent’s Role in Marketing: Agents are generally not publicists. They can advise on marketing strategies, connect you with publicists, and advocate for your book internally at the publishing house, but they won’t manage your social media or book talks. Clarify their role here.
  • Contract Review (for Subsequent Books): Even with the same publisher, each book contract will have unique terms. Your agent should review these diligently on your behalf, negotiating the best possible terms for you.

Pitfall 8: Ignoring Red Flags in a Long-Term Relationship

The Problem: Loyalty can sometimes override common sense. Writers might ignore consistent unresponsiveness, lack of sales, or repeated disagreements because they feel obligated or afraid to start over. This can stagnate a career.

Actionable Solution: Regularly Assess the Relationship and Act Decisively When Necessary.

  • Performance Review: Annually, or when a major project concludes, assess your agent relationship. Are you happy with their communication? Their advocacy? Their sales performance for you? Are they still passionate about your work?
  • Address Concerns Directy: If you’re unhappy, schedule a candid conversation. Clearly articulate your concerns. Give them a chance to address them.
    • Example: “I’m feeling a bit frustrated by the lack of traction on [Project B] and the infrequent updates. Can we discuss what we can do to get it moving again and establish a clearer communication rhythm?”
  • Know When to Walk Away: If the relationship is consistently unproductive, strained, or detrimental, be prepared to terminate the agreement. Review your termination clause, follow its steps precisely, and be prepared for a period of being unrepresented as you seek a new agent. It’s better to be unrepresented and able to actively seek the right fit than to be poorly represented and stuck.
    • Steps for Termination (General Example):
      1. Review Contract: Thoroughly understand the termination clause.
      2. Formal Notice: Send a written, formal notice of termination, preferably via certified mail, stating the date of termination as per the contract.
      3. Request Submission List: Ask for a comprehensive list of all editors/publishers your manuscript(s) are currently submitted to. This is crucial for transparency and for any future agent.
      4. Confirm Financials: Request a final statement of accounts.
      5. Remove Representation: Update your website and professional profiles.
      6. Seek New Agent: Begin a new, informed search, being transparent with potential new agents about your previous representation (without badmouthing your former agent).

Conclusion: Empowering Your Authorial Journey

Avoiding common agent pitfalls is less about being cynical and more about being informed, proactive, and discerning. The agent-client relationship, at its best, is a powerful partnership built on trust, mutual respect, and shared goals. By understanding the potential challenges, equipping yourself with the right questions, rigorously vetting potential agents, and taking an active role in managing your career, you transform from a hopeful amateur into a savvy professional. Your book, your career, and your peace of mind depend on it. Invest the time and effort upfront to secure a truly symbiotic relationship that propels your writing forward, rather than holding it back.