How to Interview Athletes for Compelling Sports Stories

by

Sports are so much more than just a game. You feel the roar of the crowd, you see the cameras flash, and you can sense the immense pressure on these athletes. But you know, the really captivating stories aren’t always about the score itself. They live deep inside the athlete – the quiet struggles, those defining moments, and all the wisdom they gain from winning and losing. To truly get at these stories, you need more than just a recorder. You need a strategic, empathetic, and incredibly skilled way of talking to them. If you’re a writer wanting to turn typical sports recaps into truly human dramas, learning how to interview athletes is absolutely crucial.

Now, I’m going to break down the whole interview process for you. I’ll give you real strategies and concrete examples to help you uncover the authenticity and depth that truly connects with your readers. We’re going beyond the superficial, diving into advanced techniques that will turn your interviews into treasure troves for amazing sports stories.

Getting Started: Research, Respect, and Giving Back

Before you even ask a single question, you have to do some serious groundwork. This isn’t about memorizing facts; it’s about genuinely understanding them and building a foundation of trust.

Really Dig into Their Journey, Not Just Their Stats

Every athlete has that public image, but the story you’re after is probably underneath all of that. Don’t fall into the trap of only looking at easily found stats or recent game highlights.

  • My Advice: Go way past the box scores. Research their entire career. Did they bounce back from a terrible injury? Were they a superstar in high school but struggled in college? Did they play multiple sports? Did they come from an unusual background? Look for those pivotal moments, coaches who really shaped them, family dynamics if they’re public about it, and what first made them love their sport.
    • For Example: Instead of saying, “You had 25 points last night,” try, “I was reading about your junior year in college, when you barely played. Can you talk about how you got through that time and how it affects how you play now?” This shows you’ve done your homework beyond the obvious.
  • My Advice: Look through previous interviews (print, video, audio) for recurring themes, things that annoy them, or topics they clearly love talking about. Find areas where they might have avoided answering or where their answers felt incomplete. You’re not trying to copy them, but to spot those gaps and chances for deeper questions.
    • For Example: If you notice they always dodge questions about a certain coaching change, bring it up indirectly later in the interview, maybe by asking about professional transitions in general.

Understand Their World: Team Dynamics and Sport Specifics

An athlete rarely exists in a bubble. Their story is often tied in with their team, their sport’s culture, and bigger trends in athletics.

  • My Advice: Get comfortable with the specific language of their sport, the unwritten rules, and all the strategic details. This immediately builds credibility. You don’t have to be an expert, but you need to show you understand.
    • For Example: If you’re interviewing a baseball pitcher, understanding the difference between a four-seam fastball and a two-seamer, or what “pitching backwards” means, will let you ask more precise and insightful questions. “Can you walk me through the sequence where you got that strikeout on the low-and-away slider? What were you seeing from the batter at that moment?” is much better than “How did you get that strikeout?”
  • My Advice: Research the team’s history, rivalries, coaching philosophies, and key support staff. These things often explain an athlete’s experiences and decisions.
    • For Example: If a team just got a new coach, instead of asking, “How do you feel about the new coach?” you might ask, “Considering the strategic changes under Coach [New Coach’s Name], how have you personally adjusted your training or your in-game approach?” This acknowledges the change without being accusatory.

How to Ask: Getting the Interview

Getting access is often the first hurdle. Your approach has to be professional, to the point, and show them why your story matters.

  • My Advice: Be clear about your story’s angle and what makes it unique. Avoid really vague requests like “I want to interview you for a story.”
    • For Example: Instead of “I’m writing a story about your team,” try, “I’m working on a piece about the mental strength it takes to come back from a career-threatening injury, and your journey back to the ice after your ACL tear is incredibly compelling. I’d love to speak with you for 20 minutes about that specific side of your career.”
  • My Advice: Be respectful of their time. Suggest a clear time frame and stick to it. Offer flexibility.
    • For Example: “Would 15-20 minutes after practice on Tuesday work, or is there another time that’s more convenient for you?”
  • My Advice: Use any existing connections you might have, if possible. A recommendation from a PR person, coach, or even another athlete can really boost your chances.

The Interview Itself: Beyond the Basics

This is where things truly come alive. Moving past those surface-level questions needs a nuanced way of asking, deeply listening, and being able to adapt on the fly.

Creating the Right Space: Comfort and Connection

The setting and your demeanor hugely impact the quality of the answers you get.

  • My Advice: Pick a quiet spot if you can, free from distractions. If you’re in a locker room or a noisy press conference, try to create a little bubble of focus.
  • My Advice: Start with warm-up questions that build a connection and help the athlete relax. Don’t jump right into sensitive topics. These can be light, harmless questions about their day, travel, or even their pre-game routine.
    • For Example: “Thanks for making time. Long day of practice today, I imagine? How do you usually unwind after a session like that?” Or, “Hey [Athlete’s Name], how was the flight in? I hear you guys had a bit of a delay.”
  • My Advice: Keep eye contact. Your body language shows how sincere you are. Lean in sometimes to show you’re engaged. Subtly mirroring their actions can also help build a connection.

The Art of Asking: Being Precise, Open, and Focusing on “How” and “Why”

This is the heart of a good interview. Your questions should be designed to get a story, emotions, and insights, not just facts.

  • My Advice: Prioritize open-ended questions that can’t just be answered with a “yes” or “no.” Use “how,” “what,” “why,” and “tell me about” prompts.
    • For Example: Instead of “Was it tough competing for that starting spot?” try, “Can you walk me through the emotions and challenges of competing for that starting spot when you first joined the team?”
  • My Advice: Use the “peel the onion” technique. When an athlete gives a short answer, ask follow-up questions that dig deeper into the emotion, the decisions, or the impact.
    • For Example:
      • Athlete: “Winning that championship was incredible.”
      • Me: “Incredible how? Can you describe the feeling the moment the final whistle blew? What was running through your mind?”
      • Athlete: “Just pure relief.”
      • Me: “Relief from what specifically? The pressure, the long season, the doubters? What weight was lifted in that moment?”
  • My Advice: Focus on the process, not just the outcome. The steps they took, the choices they made, the effort they put in – these are often more gripping than just the score.
    • For Example: Instead of “How did you feel when you missed the winning shot?” try, “Can you describe your thought process in the final seconds of that game, leading up to that last shot attempt? What were you seeing, feeling, and trying to execute?” This moves from a judgmental outcome to a narrative of the moment.
  • My Advice: Ask “story questions.” These are designed to trigger a narrative with a beginning, middle, and end.
    • For Example: “Can you tell me about a time in your career when you faced really tough adversity, and how you eventually overcame it? Walk me through what happened from your perspective.”
  • My Advice: Use hypothetical scenarios carefully. These can help an athlete consider possibilities or reflect on choices.
    • For Example: “If you could go back to your rookie year knowing what you know now, what advice would you give your younger self about dealing with the pressures of professional sports?”
  • My Advice: Avoid leading questions that put words in their mouth or assume an emotion.
    • For Example: Instead of “You must have been devastated after that loss, right?” try, “How did that loss impact you personally, and what was the team’s reaction in the locker room afterwards?”

Really Listening: The Unsung Hero

It’s not just about what you ask, it’s about what you hear. Truly listening is essential for getting that deep insight.

  • My Advice: Listen for emotional clues, changes in their tone, moments of hesitation, or passion. These often signal areas worth exploring further.
  • My Advice: Don’t be afraid of silence. It can feel awkward, but often, the athlete will fill it with more profound thoughts or details. Resist the urge to jump in too quickly.
  • My Advice: Take concise, relevant notes instead of trying to write down every word. Your focus should be on their responses, not your pen. Immediately jot down any follow-up ideas that come to mind from their answers.
    • For Example: If they mention a specific coach, make a mental or quick written note: ‘Ask about Coach X’s influence.’ If they use a striking metaphor, write it down.

Navigating Sensitive Topics: Empathy and Boundaries

Some of the most powerful stories come from vulnerability. Approach these topics with extreme care.

  • My Advice: Ask permission before diving into potentially sensitive areas. Give them an “out.”
    • For Example: “I read about your brother’s struggles with injury. Is that something you’d be comfortable discussing, and how it might have influenced your understanding of resilience?” This allows them to decline gracefully.
  • My Advice: Frame questions empathetically, focusing on their experience and perspective, rather than making assumptions or judgmental statements.
    • For Example (Injury): Instead of “How bad was that injury?” try, “Can you describe the initial moments after the injury? What was the hardest part of the recovery process, both physically and mentally?”
    • For Example (Conflict): Instead of “Why did you clash with your former coach?” try, “Reflecting on your past experience with Coach [Name], how did that period challenge you as an athlete, and what lessons did you takeaway?”
  • My Advice: Be prepared if they don’t answer or give very limited answers. Respect their boundaries. Pushing too hard can damage your rapport for future interactions.
  • My Advice: If emotion surfaces (tears, anger, intense frustration), acknowledge it empathetically without exploiting it. “Take your time. No rush.” Your presence should be supportive, not predatory.

After the Interview: Getting the Most Out of Your Material

The interview isn’t over when the athlete leaves. The crucial steps that follow separate good stories from truly great ones.

The Immediate Download: Catching the Nuances

Your memory is unreliable. Act quickly.

  • My Advice: Right after the interview, before transcribing, write down your key takeaways, observed body language, any striking quotes, and moments of high emotion. These are the details a transcript won’t capture.
    • For Example: “Subject teared up when discussing father’s illness. Paused for 10 seconds before continuing. Looked away.” This adds layers to your writing later.
  • My Advice: Jot down any potential narrative arcs that emerged, compelling anecdotes, or surprising revelations.
    • For Example: “He spoke extensively about his pre-game superstition – there’s a strong character piece there about ritual and control.”

Transcription and Analysis: Finding the Gold

Raw audio is just that – raw. The real work starts when you analyze it.

  • My Advice: Transcribe the interview as accurately as possible. Use AI transcription services, but always proofread meticulously yourself to catch errors and identify who’s speaking.
  • My Advice: As you review the transcript, highlight powerful quotes, vivid descriptions, metaphors, and moments of genuine vulnerability.
  • My Advice: Look for patterns in their language, repeated phrases, core beliefs, and recurring struggles or triumphs. These often reveal deeper truths.
    • For Example: If an athlete repeatedly uses battle-related metaphors (“it was a grind,” “we fought hard,” “a war”), it tells you something about their mindset and the narrative you can build around their competitive spirit.
  • My Advice: Identify any contradictions or areas that need more thought, even if you can’t interview them again. These can provide interesting angles for your narrative.

Building the Story: From Raw Material to Riveting Read

Your interview is the raw ore; now you have to refine and polish it into a diamond.

  • My Advice: Don’t just string quotes together. Weave the athlete’s insights into a rich narrative framework. Use your research as context, your observations as atmosphere, and their words as validation.
  • My Advice: Pinpoint the central conflict, the turning points, and the ultimate resolution (or ongoing challenge) in the athlete’s story.
  • My Advice: Use direct quotes wisely. The most impactful quotes are often the shortest, most profound, or those that reveal a unique insight or emotion. Long, rambling quotes often lose their punch.
  • My Advice: Prioritize “show, don’t tell.” Let the athlete’s descriptions and emotional responses demonstrate their experience, rather than you simply stating it.
    • For Example: Instead of “He was very determined,” use his quote: “There were days I couldn’t feel my legs, but the thought of letting my team down… that’s what got me out of bed.”

Thinking Ethically: Beyond the Soundbite

Your responsibility as a writer goes beyond just getting the story. It includes treating your subjects ethically.

  • My Advice: Accuracy is crucial. Don’t misquote, misrepresent, or pick quotes out of context to fit a narrative you already have in mind.
  • My Advice: Respect off-the-record conversations. If an athlete asks for something to be off-the-record, honor that request without exception.
  • My Advice: Consider how your story will impact the athlete. While your main duty is to your reader, sensationalism at the expense of an individual’s well-being is rarely good journalism. Aim for depth and insight, not scandal.
  • My Advice: Be transparent about your intentions. If you plan to focus on a particularly vulnerable aspect, let them know when you set up the interview, don’t surprise them with it.

Growing as an Interviewer: A Lifelong Journey

Mastering the athlete interview is a continuous process of refinement and self-awareness.

  • My Advice: Seriously reflect on every interview. What went well? What didn’t? What questions could have been better? What opportunities did you miss?
  • My Advice: Learn from others. Read compelling sports narratives and try to figure out how the author got their insights. Watch and analyze great interviewers.
  • My Advice: Practice, practice, practice. The more you have these kinds of conversations, the more intuitive and effective your approach will become.

By taking this comprehensive and empathetic approach, you can move past just analyzing the surface of sport, uncovering the profound human stories that are at the core of athletic achievement. Your goal isn’t just to report; it’s to reveal, to connect, and to craft narratives that resonate long after the final whistle.