How to Plot a Historical Fiction

by

Historical fiction, at its heart, is a delicate dance between fact and imagination. It’s about breathing life into the past, not just recounting it. This guide outlines a definitive, actionable framework for plotting a historical novel, ensuring both authenticity and compelling narrative.

The Ironclad Foundation: Research Before Everything

Before a single plot point is sketched, before a character’s name is chosen, comes the relentless pursuit of knowledge. This isn’t just about dates and events; it’s about the very texture of existence in your chosen era.

Deep Dive: Chronology, Culture, and Context

  • Master the Timeline: Understand the precise sequence of events relevant to your story. If you’re writing about the American Civil War, know the major battles, political shifts, and social climate leading up to and throughout the conflict. Example: For a novel set during the French Revolution, don’t just know “Storming of the Bastille.” Understand the growing aristocratic inequality, the Enlightenment ideals fueling dissent, and the King’s weakening power that made such an event inevitable.
  • Immerse in the Micro/Macro:
    • Macro: Grasp the dominant political, economic, and social systems. What were the major powers? How did wealth accumulate or distribute? What were the class structures? Example: In Viking Age Denmark, understand the chieftaincies, the importance of longships for trade and raiding, and the polytheistic religious beliefs.
    • Micro: Dive into the minutiae of daily life. What did people eat? What did they wear? How did they travel? What were common greetings, superstitions, or forms of entertainment? Failure here shatters immersion. Example: Don’t have a medieval peasant casually sipping coffee – it wasn’t introduced to Europe until centuries later. Instead, perhaps they drink ale or watered wine.
  • Understand the “Why”: Beyond what happened, explore why it happened. What were the motivations? What were the prevailing philosophies of your period? This imbues your plot with believable cause and effect. Example: If your story is set during the Roaring Twenties, understand not just jazz clubs and flappers, but the post-WWI economic boom, the rejection of Victorian morals, and the nascent women’s suffrage movement that shaped the era’s hedonism.

The Art of Historical Accuracy vs. Narrative Necessity

Historical accuracy is paramount, but it cannot always dictate your plot entirely.

  • The 95% Rule: Aim for 95% verifiable accuracy. The remaining 5% is your narrative wiggle room. This means you can invent characters, minor events, or private conversations, but they must always feel true to the period and never contradict established historical fact.
  • Don’t Re-write History: Your personal struggles, romantic entanglements, or thrilling adventures cannot alter the outcome of significant historical events. Your fictional protagonist cannot single-handedly prevent the fall of Rome. Their arc must exist within the historical framework. Example: A character in Blockade Runner during the American Civil War might undertake a perilous journey to deliver supplies, but the blockades themselves and the Union victory remain untouched.
  • The “Rule of Plausibility”: If you must invent, ensure it’s plausible within the historical context. Would a medieval knight genuinely encounter an alien spaceship? No. Would a Regency-era lady secretly participate in a forbidden intellectual society? Perhaps, if carefully set up.

Crafting the Compelling Core: Bridging History and Human Experience

Once the historical foundation is solid, you begin to weave your narrative through it. This is where your human story intersects with grand historical currents.

Identify Your Historical Anchor Point(s)

  • The Specific Event: Is your story centered around the eruption of Vesuvius, the execution of Anne Boleyn, or the Berlin Airlift? This event provides a natural focal point and often dictates the timeline. Example: If your story begins just before the San Francisco Earthquake of 1906, that event will naturally drive much of the initial plot’s conflict and character reaction.
  • The Era/Movement: Is it broader – the Ming Dynasty, the Jazz Age, the American Civil Rights Movement? Here, your plot may explore various facets of the era, with specific events serving as milestones. Example: A novel set during the California Gold Rush might follow prospectors, merchants, and saloon owners, with events like new gold strikes or native conflicts shaping their journeys.
  • The “Hidden” History: Sometimes, the most compelling stories emerge from lesser-known aspects of a period – the lives of ordinary people, forgotten social groups, or untold cultural practices. These often provide rich ground for original plots. Example: A story centered on the female codebreakers of Bletchley Park during WWII offers a fresh perspective beyond the battlefields.

The Protagonist: A Product of Their Time, Yet Universally Relatable

Your protagonist is the reader’s window into the past. They must be authentic to their era but possess relatable human struggles.

  • Period Mentality, Not Modern Morality: Crucially, your characters must think and act within the prevailing mindset of their time. Do not impose 21st-century values onto an 18th-century character. This is one of the most common pitfalls. Example: A character in ancient Rome would not conceive of individual human rights in the way we do post-Enlightenment. Their concerns might revolve around honor, family, or civic duty as Romans understand it.
  • Universal Themes: While period-specific, their core struggles should resonate. Love, loss, ambition, betrayal, courage, fear – these are timeless. A Roman soldier’s longing for home is relatable, even if the specifics of his journey are ancient.
  • The “Outsider” or “Insider” Archetype:
    • Insider: A character deeply embedded in the historical world. Their arc might involve challenging the norms or surviving the pressures of their society. Example: A noblewoman in Elizabethan England navigating court intrigue.
    • Outsider: A character who, for some reason, doesn’t quite fit or comes from a different background. This allows for commentary on the norms of the time. Example: An escaped slave seeking freedom on the Underground Railroad, encountering various facets of antebellum American society.

The Plot Arc: Weaving Personal and Historical Destinies

This is where the magic happens – where your character’s journey intertwines with the larger tapestry of history.

The Inciting Incident: Where Worlds Collide

Your protagonist’s ordinary world is disrupted by an event, often directly linked to the historical context.

  • Personal Spark, Historical Fuel: The inciting incident should be personal to your protagonist but ignited by the historical setting. Example: For a novel about the American Revolution, the protagonist isn’t just “called to adventure.” Perhaps their farm is seized by British soldiers, or a loved one is unjustly imprisoned, directly forcing them to choose a side.
  • Irreversible Change: This event sets them on a new, unavoidable path.

Rising Action: Consequence and Escalation

The protagonist faces challenges that are both personal and historically contextualized. Each challenge escalates stakes.

  • The Pinch Points of History: Use key historical events as “pinch points” that directly impact your character. Example: If your character is a spy in WWII London, the Blitz isn’t just background noise; it forms a perilous backdrop for their missions, destroying safe houses or separating them from contacts.
  • Internal vs. External Conflict:
    • External: The dangers of war, political oppression, natural disaster, social injustice.
    • Internal: The character’s internal struggles with their beliefs, their morality, their past, their courage in the face of these historical forces.
  • Subplots with Purpose: Any subplots (romance, secondary character arcs) must contribute to the main plot or deepen the historical immersion. Avoid gratuitous diversions. Example: A love affair during the California Gold Rush isn’t just about romance; it might highlight the societal anxieties about gender roles or the desperate transient nature of life in the boomtowns.

The Climax: History and Humanity Converge

The peak of both the historical and personal conflict. The protagonist makes their most significant decision or faces their greatest challenge.

  • Resolution and Ramification: The climax should provide a resolution for the main conflict, but not necessarily a “happy” one, especially if your historical period was tumultuous. The historical event reaches its peak, and your character directly interacts with its consequences.
  • Character Arc Fulfilled: The protagonist’s journey culminates here, showcasing their transformation. They have either succeeded, failed, or learned a profound truth about themselves and their world. Example: A character deeply involved in the French Revolution might find themselves on the wrong side during the Reign of Terror, their idealism shattered, forcing them to make a desperate choice for survival, even as the guillotines fall.

Falling Action and Resolution: The Lingering Echoes

The immediate aftermath of the climax, showing the consequences and the beginning of a new status quo. The historical event settles, and your character adapts.

  • Realistic Aftermath: History doesn’t always have clean endings. Show the messy aftermath, the rebuilding, the reckoning.
  • The “So What?”: What is the lasting impact of the historical event and the character’s journey on their future? How have they changed? Example: After surviving the Black Death, a character might be permanently altered by the loss and societal shifts, perhaps becoming an apothecary, directly using the knowledge gained from that horrific period.

The Plotter’s Toolkit: Structuring for Success

While the above provides the core, specific tools refine the plotting process.

The Historical Event Outline

Create a separate, detailed timeline of just the historical events, even those not directly impacting your plot. This is your master reference.

  • Key Dates: Significant historical dates, political changes, technological advancements, cultural shifts.
  • Major Players: Key historical figures, their motivations, their influence.
  • Social Realities: Economic conditions, laws, prevailing attitudes, everyday life details.

The Character Arc Mapping

  • Want vs. Need: What does your character think they want at the beginning of the story (often superficial desires tied to the period)? What do they truly need (a deeper, universal human truth)? Example: A young woman in Victorian England might want to find a suitable husband (Want), but what she truly needs is independence and intellectual fulfillment (Need).
  • Transformative Journey: How does the historical setting and the ensuing plot force them to confront their want/need and ultimately change?

The Scene-by-Scene Breakdown

Once you have a high-level plot, break it down chapter by chapter, then scene by scene.

  • Purpose for Every Scene: Each scene must advance the historical plot, the personal plot, or both. If it doesn’t, cut it.
  • Information Delivery: How will you weave in historical details organically? Not through infodumps, but through character action, dialogue, or description. Example: Instead of stating “the streets of London were cobbled,” have your character stumble on uneven stones, making a point about the poor sanitation or challenging the pace of horse-drawn carriages.
  • Show, Don’t Tell History: Never simply state facts. Show them through the lived experience of your characters. Example: Instead of saying “there was a plague,” show a character tending to sick family members, the fear in their eyes, the empty streets, the carts collecting bodies.

Incorporating Conflict and Stakes

  • Historical Oppression/Restriction: Use the time period’s social norms, laws, or prevailing attitudes as sources of conflict. Example: Women’s limited rights, class barriers, racial prejudice, religious persecution.
  • Technological Limitations: The absence of modern technology provides natural obstacles. Communication, travel, medicine were all vastly different. Example: Delivering a message across continents in the 17th century took months and was fraught with danger, unlike an instant email today.
  • The “Ticking Clock” of History: If your plot is tied to a specific historical event, that event provides a natural deadline. Example: The Battle of Gettysburg provides a finite time frame for characters whose fate is tied to its outcome.

The Fine Print: Nuances for Authenticity and Engagement

Beyond structure, several subtleties elevate a historical fiction plot.

Language and Dialogue: Evocative, Not Archaic

  • Period Flavor, Not Impenetrable: Your characters should sound like they belong to their time, but avoid overly archaic language that alienates modern readers. A dash of period idiom works; a deluge does not.
  • Reflect Class and Education: Dialogue should also reflect the character’s social standing and education level. A street urchin in Victorian London will not speak like a duke.

Setting as a Character

  • Sensory Immersion: Describe the smells, sounds, sights, and textures of the period. This goes beyond visual descriptions. What did a medieval market smell like? What was the constant noise of a bustling industrial city?
  • Impact on Plot: How does the physical setting (a dense urban slum, a vast prairie, a cramped ship’s hold) influence your characters’ actions and the unfolding plot? Example: A character stranded in the vast, untamed American West faces different survival challenges than one trapped in a besieged European city.

The Morality Question

  • Avoid Presentism: Do not judge historical characters by modern moral standards. Understand their choices within the ethical framework of their society, not ours. Example: A slave owner in the American South, though morally reprehensible by today’s standards, viewed their actions through the lens of their era’s pervasive legal and social constructs. This isn’t endorsement, but understanding for authentic portrayal.

The “What If” vs. “What Was”

  • “What Was” is Your Canvas: Your plot explores what was and puts characters within that reality.
  • “What If” for Character Choices: The “what if” belongs to your characters’ choices within the established historical facts, not changing the facts themselves. Example: What if a real historical figure had made a different personal decision at a crossroads? This is fertile ground.

The Unwavering Commitment: Iteration and Refinement

Plotting historical fiction is not a linear process. It’s iterative.

  • Research Loop: As you plot, new questions will arise that require more research. Embrace this loop.
  • Flexibility: Be prepared to adjust your plot if new research unearths a crucial, unalterable historical detail that contradicts your initial idea. The history dictates the bounds of your fiction, not the other way around.
  • Beta Readers with a Historical Eye: Seek out beta readers who have knowledge of your chosen period, or at least a sharp eye for historical inconsistency. They can catch errors your dedicated research might have missed.

Mastering the plot of historical fiction requires both the rigor of a historian and the imagination of a storyteller. It’s about building a sturdy, accurate, period-appropriate house, then filling it with vibrant, relatable lives. The result is a profoundly immersive experience that educates as it entertains, transporting the reader not just to a different place, but to a different time.