How to Write Rejection Emails Professionally.

by

So, you know how busy the digital world is, right? Full of chances, but also super competitive. And sometimes, if you’re a writer, you end up in this tricky spot where you have to tell someone “no.”

Maybe you’re a literary agent passing on a manuscript, an editor saying no to a pitch, or a hiring manager letting a candidate know someone else got the job. Giving professional “no” emails isn’t just about ticking a box; it’s a huge deal for your reputation, for building good vibes, and keeping those professional connections strong. This isn’t about sugar-coating things or trying to avoid tough conversations. It’s about being respectful, clear, and understanding so the person getting the email still feels valued, even if they’re disappointed.

I’m going to break down how to write these professional rejection emails. We’ll go beyond just using generic templates. I want you to really grasp why certain ways of doing things work, and how you can actually make them happen. We’re going to dive into how rejection feels, why being thoughtful in your communication is smart, and how to put all this into practice. My goal is that your rejection emails won’t just be sent, they’ll be appreciated.

The Hidden Power of a Good Rejection

Before we even start thinking about what to type, it’s super important to get how much a well-written rejection can do. This is a real moment of truth for your brand, your ethics, and how much you care about being professional. A quickly written, thoughtless email can trash your reputation, make people not want to work with you in the future, and even cause public drama. But, on the flip side, a thoughtful, respectful rejection can actually make people think positively of you, even the ones you’ve turned down. It builds respect, keeps future doors open (if that’s a possibility), and shows everyone you’re fair and considerate.

Think about it like this: that writer you just rejected might be perfect for a different project later on, or they might even tell their friends about you. How they feel after reading your rejection email directly impacts those future chances. This isn’t just about closing a door; it’s about acknowledging someone’s effort and showing them respect.

Section 1: The Basics – Building a Solid Foundation

Every really good rejection email needs strong core principles. If you ignore these, it’s like building a house without a foundation – it’s just going to fall apart eventually.

Principle 1.1: Be Timely – This is Key

Waiting too long to send a rejection is way worse than just sending it. Long silences just breed anxiety and resentment. When someone has poured their time, energy, and hope into an application, a pitch, or a submission, they deserve a prompt answer, even if it’s a “no.”

  • My Advice: Set up a timeline for reviewing submissions and stick to it. If you know there might be delays, send a quick update acknowledging you got their submission and setting realistic expectations for when they’ll hear back.
  • Example (If There’s a Delay):
    “Subject: Update on Your Submission to [Your Company/Project Name]

    Hi [Applicant Name],

    Thanks again for your awesome submission. We’re currently getting a really high number of entries, and we’re working hard to give each one the careful attention it deserves. We expect to finish our review process by [Date] and will send out our decision then.

    We really appreciate your patience and continued interest.

    Best,

    [Your Name/Team]”

Principle 1.2: Be Clear and Direct – No Room for Confusion

Ambiguity is the enemy when you’re communicating professionally, especially with a rejection. Don’t beat around the bush or use vague language that leaves the person guessing. State your decision clearly and without a doubt.

  • My Advice: Use straightforward, clear phrases like “We’ve decided not to move forward with your application,” or “Your pitch doesn’t quite fit our current needs.”
  • Example (Being Direct):
    “Subject: Regarding Your Application for the [Position Name] Role at [Company Name]

    Hi [Applicant Name],

    Thanks so much for applying for the [Position Name] role at [Company Name]. We appreciate you taking the time to apply and learn more about us.

    While your qualifications are really impressive, we’ve decided to move forward with other candidates whose experience is a closer match for the specific requirements of this role right now.”

Principle 1.3: Empathy and Respect – Acknowledging Their Effort

Behind every single submission is a person who put in time, talent, and hope. Acknowledge their effort and genuinely show respect for their work. This doesn’t mean you need to be overly sympathetic or overly apologetic, but rather recognize their humanity.

  • My Advice: Start with a polite opening, thank them for their time and interest, and mention the specific submission if you can.
  • Example (Showing You Appreciate Their Effort):
    “Subject: Your Submission for [Publication Name]

    Hi [Writer Name],

    Thanks for submitting your piece, ‘[Article Title],’ to [Publication Name]. We really appreciate you thinking of us and sending your work our way.”

Principle 1.4: Professional Tone – Stay Objective

Even while being empathetic, keep your tone professional and objective. Avoid being too casual, getting emotional, or making excuses that can sound defensive or fake. Your goal is to inform, not to argue or comfort.

  • My Advice: Read through your email to catch any overly emotional words or phrases. Keep it formal but still easy to read.
  • Example (Keeping it Professional):
    “We received a high volume of exceptionally strong submissions, making our selection process particularly competitive.” (Instead of: “It was, like, really hard, everyone was so good, we just couldn’t pick yours, it was tough!”)

Section 2: The Key Parts of a Great Rejection Email

Alright, let’s break down the essential pieces that almost every professional rejection email should have.

Component 2.1: The Clear and Short Subject Line

The subject line is the very first thing people see and it sets the whole vibe. It needs to be clear, professional, and tell them what the email is about without being overly alarming.

  • My Advice: Include relevant details (like the job title, project name, or manuscript title) and a polite hint about the email’s purpose.
  • Examples:
    • “Update on Your Application for [Position Name] role at [Company Name]”
    • “Regarding Your Submission to [Publication Name]”
    • “Status of Your Literary Submission – [Manuscript Title]”
    • “Response to Your Pitch: [Pitch Topic]”

Component 2.2: The Polite Opening and Thank You

Always start with a thank you. It immediately shows you respect their time and effort.

  • My Advice: Thank them specifically for their application, submission, or proposal. Mention the specific item if you can.
  • Examples:
    • “Thank you for your interest in the [Position Name] role at [Company Name] and for taking the time to interview with our team.”
    • “Thank you for submitting your manuscript, ‘[Manuscript Title],’ for our consideration.”
    • “We appreciate you sending over your detailed pitch for the [Project Name] initiative.”

Component 2.3: The Direct Statement of Decision

This is where you deliver the news. Be direct, clear, and absolutely unambiguous.

  • My Advice: Use phrases that clearly state the decision without any room for misunderstanding.
  • Examples:
    • “While your qualifications are impressive, we have decided not to move forward with your application at this time.”
    • “After careful consideration, we regret to inform you that we will not be able to offer you a position at this time.”
    • “We have completed our review and, unfortunately, your submission does not align with our current editorial needs.”
    • “We’ve decided to pursue a different direction for this project.”

Component 2.4: A Brief, General Reason (Optional but Recommended)

Giving a brief, general reason can make the news a little easier to take and offer a bit of understanding without inviting a debate. It’s super important that these reasons are general to avoid legal issues, detailed critiques, or arguments. Focus on your internal reasons rather than what they might have done “wrong.”

  • My Advice: Frame the reason around your needs, your criteria, or how competitive the selection process was. Don’t give personal critiques or advice unless that’s part of a service you offer (like a formal manuscript critique).
  • Examples:
    • “The competitive nature of our candidate pool for this role meant we had to make a very difficult decision.”
    • “We ultimately selected a candidate whose experience was a closer match for the immediate needs of our team.” (For job applications)
    • “While your piece was well-written, it wasn’t quite the right fit for the specific themes we are exploring in our upcoming issue.” (For publications)
    • “We received an exceptionally high volume of strong submissions, and our selections were based on our current strategic priorities.” (For competitive grants/awards)
    • “The subject matter, while interesting, does not align with our current focus for new acquisitions.” (For literary agents)

Component 2.5: The Forward-Looking or Encouraging Close

End on a positive, professional note. Wish them well and maybe even encourage them to apply again in the future if it’s truly appropriate.

  • My Advice: Offer a polite closing statement. If there’s a genuine possibility for future opportunities, a general “keep in touch” or “good luck with future endeavors” is a good fit.
  • Examples:
    • “We wish you the best in your job search and future endeavors.”
    • “We wish you the very best in placing your manuscript elsewhere.”
    • “We truly appreciate your interest and wish you success with your future writing projects.”
    • “Thank you again for your time and interest. We wish you success in your professional pursuits.”

Component 2.6: The Professional Sign-Off

Always use a professional closing and make sure your name and relevant contact info are there.

  • My Advice: Use standard professional closings like “Sincerely,” “Best regards,” or “Respectfully.”
  • Examples:
    • Sincerely,
      [Your Name]
      [Your Title/Company Name]

    • Best regards,
      The Editorial Board
      [Publication Name]

Section 3: Little Twists and Smart Tactics – Leveling Up Your Rejection Emails

Beyond the basics, these strategies will help you handle specific situations and really master the art of professional rejection.

Strategy 3.1: Tailoring the Message (When it Makes Sense)

Templates are efficient, but adding a personal touch can make a big difference. This is especially true if someone has reached a later stage of a process (like after an interview or multiple rounds of review) or if they’re a really important connection.

  • My Advice: Briefly mention something specific from their application, a particularly good answer during an interview, or a unique part of their submission. Keep it short.
  • Example (After an Interview):
    “Subject: Update on Your Application for the [Position Name] Role at [Company Name]

    Hi [Applicant Name],

    Thank you for your application for the [Position Name] role at [Company Name]. We really enjoyed meeting you last week and learning more about your experience, especially your insights into [specific project/skill discussed].

    While your qualifications are impressive, we’ve decided to move forward with other candidates whose experience is a closer match for the specific requirements of this role right now. The competitive nature of our candidate pool meant we had to make a very tough decision.

    We wish you the best in your job search and future endeavors.

    Best,

    [Your Name/Hiring Manager]”

Strategy 3.2: The “Keep on File” Clause (Use with Caution)

Some places use a “keep on file” phrase. Only offer this if you genuinely plan to do it and if there’s a real possibility of a future role. Otherwise, it gives false hope.

  • My Advice: If you use it, be very specific, like: “We will keep your resume on file for future opportunities that may align more closely with your skills, if they come up.”
  • Example (Careful “Keep on File”):
    “We’ve noted your strong skills in [specific area] and will keep your profile on file should a more suitable opening arise in the future that aligns with your expertise. Please continue to monitor our careers page for new listings.”

Strategy 3.3: Managing Expectations for Feedback

Often, people who are rejected will ask for feedback. Generally, giving detailed feedback in rejection emails is risky. It can lead to long discussions, legal issues, or arguments.

  • My Advice: Decide on your internal policy: no feedback, or only very general feedback. State this policy clearly if you expect requests.
  • Example (Declining Feedback):
    “Due to the high volume of applications we receive, we are unable to provide individualized feedback at this stage of the process.” (This is a common and totally acceptable practice.)

  • Example (Very General Feedback – Use with EXTREME caution and only if you have a consistent internal reason):
    “While your writing showed a strong narrative voice, we were looking for a submission with a more distinct thematic focus for this particular issue.” (This should ideally be a pre-approved, general reason you use consistently, not a specific critique of their work unless you are actually offering a critique service.)

Strategy 3.4: Handling Internal vs. External Rejections

How you reject an internal candidate might be a little different from an external one. Internal rejections need even more sensitivity to keep morale high and preserve internal relationships.

  • My Advice: For internal candidates, consider a quick in-person chat before the email, followed by a confirming email. Emphasize that they’re still valued by the company.
  • Example (Internal Candidate):
    “Subject: Update on Your Application for the [Position Name] Role

    Hi [Internal Candidate Name],

    Thanks for applying for the [Position Name] role and for taking the time to interview with the team. We truly appreciate your continued dedication to [Company Name] and your willingness to explore new opportunities within the organization.

    As we discussed, we’ve decided to move forward with another candidate whose experience provided a direct skill match for the immediate needs of this specific role.

    We value your contributions to [Current Department] and look forward to your continued success here. Please feel free to schedule a follow-up conversation if you have any questions.

    Best,

    [Your Name/Manager]”

Strategy 3.5: AI’s Role (and Its Limits)

AI tools are great for quickly generating initial drafts, keeping your tone and structure consistent. But they don’t really understand human empathy or context.

  • My Advice: Use AI for the standard bits, subject lines, and first drafts. Always, always, always personally review and edit for clarity, empathy, and accuracy. Add those specific details or that subtle human touch that AI can’t do. Never just trust AI to deliver sensitive news without your critical human review.

Section 4: What Not to Do – Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even if you mean well, some things can really mess up how professional your rejection emails come across.

Pitfall 4.1: Ghosting

The absolute worst thing you can do is not respond at all. It’s rude, unprofessional, and permanently damages your reputation.

  • What Happens: It breaks trust, causes anxiety, builds resentment, and can really hurt your brand.
  • My Action: Always send a response, even a short one, especially if you set an expectation that you’d communicate.

Pitfall 4.2: Over-Apologizing or Sounding Too Sorry

Empathy is important, but apologizing too much or sounding overly remorseful can make you seem less professional and fake. You’re making a business decision, not doing something personally offensive.

  • What Happens: Can make you sound weak, insincere, or invite appeals.
  • My Action: Be respectful and kind, but firm in your decision.

Pitfall 4.3: Giving Detailed Critiques or Advice (Unless You Offer It)

Unless you run a paid critique service, don’t give unsolicited, detailed feedback on someone’s work or qualifications. This is a common trap.

  • What Happens: Opens the door to arguments, defensiveness, and potentially false accusations of bias. It wastes your time and can even lead to legal issues.
  • My Action: Stick to general, internal reasons (like “not the right fit,” “highly competitive pool”).

Pitfall 4.4: Giving False Hope or Misleading Statements

Don’t tell someone you’ll “keep their information on file” if you won’t, or “encourage them to apply again” if they’re clearly not suitable.

  • What Happens: Damages trust, wastes their time (and yours) in the future.
  • My Action: Be honest and realistic without being harsh. If there’s truly no future for them with your organization, state the decision clearly without false optimism.

Pitfall 4.5: Blaming the Recipient

Avoid language that subtly or obviously blames the applicant for why they were rejected (e.g., “Your skills were insufficient,” “Your pitch lacked originality”).

  • What Happens: Causes defensiveness, anger, and deeply damages professional relationships.
  • My Action: Frame reasons around your organization’s needs, not the applicant’s perceived shortcomings.

Pitfall 4.6: Too Much Information (TMI)

Keep the email concise. Don’t go into details about your internal vetting processes, committee fights, or super long explanations.

  • What Happens: Overwhelms the recipient, can be confusing, and invites more questions.
  • My Action: Stick to the essential parts I talked about in Section 2.

Conclusion: Rejection as a Way of Being Professional

Writing professional rejection emails isn’t just some boring necessary task; it’s a really important part of being a responsible and ethical professional. In a world where digital interactions can feel a bit cold, a well-written rejection shows how professional you are, how much you respect other people’s time and effort, and how much you care about keeping a good reputation.

By sticking to the ideas of being timely, clear, empathetic, and respectful, and by mastering the main parts we discussed, you can turn a potentially negative interaction into a chance to show your values. Remember, every email you send, even a rejection, reflects on your brand. So make it count. Turn a moment of disappointment into a statement of professional courtesy, solidifying your place as a thoughtful and trustworthy professional in the demanding world of writing and beyond.